Live data from Hacker News

How many supernova explode every year?

badastronomy.beehiiv.com

1–10 of 196 posts

Re: How many supernova explode every year?

#4
We're dealing with the sum total of everything, if the true nature of things is that there are a finite number of supernovas I'd be surprised. The real shock is how small the number of supernovas is and how young everything seems to be in the known universe (the age of the observed universe is estimated at maybe double digit billion years).

These are tiny numbers given that we're quite possibly dealing with infinity in both time and space. I judge it one of the stronger arguments in favour of the universe being constructed (or, more likely, there is a lot out there we can't see). If god built a universe numbers like 1 supernova a century make some sense for artistic value.

Re: How many supernova explode every year?

#5
post #4

We're dealing with the sum total of everything, if the true nature of things is that there are a finite number of supernovas I'd be surprised. The real shock is how small the number of supernovas is and how young everything seems to be in the known universe (the age of the observed universe is estimated at maybe double digit billion years). These are tiny numbers given that we're quite possibly dealing with infinity…

Isn't the observable universe finite? There can't be a infinite number of anything in a space of radius R, even if R is very big.

Re: How many supernova explode every year?

#6

The whole things seems like such a massive living system that I cannot help guessing that what we think of as universe is just a somewhat large single creature.

It's an appealing idea, but surely there'd be insurmountable problems with the distance/time involved for any part to communicate to another part? It'd be like trying to run a computer with a clock that takes millions (billions?) of years to make a single tick. I just don't see that it's at all feasible and that's without even trying to guess as to how different parts can change behaviour depending on its environment (one commonly used requirement of "life").

Re: How many supernova explode every year?

#7
post #5
post #4

We're dealing with the sum total of everything, if the true nature of things is that there are a finite number of supernovas I'd be surprised. The real shock is how small the number of supernovas is and how young everything seems to be in the known universe (the age of the observed universe is estimated at maybe double digit billion years). These are tiny numbers given that we're quite possibly dealing with infinity…

Isn't the observable universe finite? There can't be a infinite number of anything in a space of radius R, even if R is very big.

Anything moving beyond the Cosmological Horizon can no longer be seen.

As I understand it, a frozen image will remain for a time and fade, growing increasingly red shifted.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmological_horizon

Re: How many supernova explode every year?

#9
That's one of my favourite hints in Outer Wilds. You will see a Supernova. Not with a fancy telescope, it's visible to the naked eye, and if you watch the sky you'll see another soon enough. You can see this right at the start, and unlike the random direction of the probe launch you don't need any game lore to, if you're smart enough, put two and two together.

Re: How many supernova explode every year?

#10
post #4

We're dealing with the sum total of everything, if the true nature of things is that there are a finite number of supernovas I'd be surprised. The real shock is how small the number of supernovas is and how young everything seems to be in the known universe (the age of the observed universe is estimated at maybe double digit billion years). These are tiny numbers given that we're quite possibly dealing with infinity…

You can't compare a number of years or events with infinity. Saying it's tiny or huge makes no sense whatsoever.

What amazes me is how young the universe is compared to life. The universe is only about 4 times as old as life on Earth.

Post reply on HN