Live data from Hacker News

LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

people.gnome.org

1–10 of 23 posts

Re: LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

#3
"German comments removal" sounds like a lot of work. It is always very annoying when programmers comment (or even name their variables/functions/whatever) using another language than English.

Most APIs are based on English so this makes a very messy combination. And yet people do it often, hindering the possibility of foreigners to contribute.

A recent example I've run into is the WYSIWYG editing extension for ShareJS, with all comments in Russian. I'd love to reuse it, but this just keeps me away:

https://github.com/rizzoma/ShareJS/blob/master/src/client/ri...

(note: I can read Cyrillic characters and do understand some Russian, but still)

Re: LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

#4

I think it's remarkable how much the LibreOffice folks have achieved compared to what was acheived when Sun was running this project!

Absolutely. Given how much cruft we'd all heard was in there, it really is amazing how they've cleaned it up. Too bad there are two competing projects, but really LO looks like the winner so far.

Re: LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

#5
Will pay a lot of money for a Linux-compatible Excel feature-parity version of a spreadsheet.

In fact, most spreadsheets today are created using OOXML, so it might be easier (notionally speaking) than the binary XLS format.

I daresay, there is a very, very large market for this - especially in Asia. I dont need the same for Word or Powerpoint - PDFs work fine in an emergency. For spreadsheets, I dont have an alternative.

Re: LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

#6
post #3

"German comments removal" sounds like a lot of work. It is always very annoying when programmers comment (or even name their variables/functions/whatever) using another language than English. Most APIs are based on English so this makes a very messy combination. And yet people do it often, hindering the possibility of foreigners to contribute. A recent example I've run into is the WYSIWYG editing extension for ShareJ…

[deleted]

Re: LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

#7
post #3

"German comments removal" sounds like a lot of work. It is always very annoying when programmers comment (or even name their variables/functions/whatever) using another language than English. Most APIs are based on English so this makes a very messy combination. And yet people do it often, hindering the possibility of foreigners to contribute. A recent example I've run into is the WYSIWYG editing extension for ShareJ…

Note that the original StarOffice was written by a German company. These comments might be in the oldest parts of the code.

Wikipedia: > The German company StarDivision in Lüneburg (founded by 16-year-old Marco Börries in 1984) wrote the original components of StarOffice

Re: LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

#8

Will pay a lot of money for a Linux-compatible Excel feature-parity version of a spreadsheet. In fact, most spreadsheets today are created using OOXML, so it might be easier (notionally speaking) than the binary XLS format. I daresay, there is a very, very large market for this - especially in Asia. I dont need the same for Word or Powerpoint - PDFs work fine in an emergency. For spreadsheets, I dont have an alternat…

It's a tough thing to do -- particularly with Excel -- many spreadsheets include VBA code and other stuff that has dependencies on other parts of the Microsoft stack.

OOXML is a beastly specification, because it's not just a description of how to create a document or spreadsheet -- it includes artifacts to maintain compatibility with MS Office software from the early 90's.

Re: LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

#9

Will pay a lot of money for a Linux-compatible Excel feature-parity version of a spreadsheet. In fact, most spreadsheets today are created using OOXML, so it might be easier (notionally speaking) than the binary XLS format. I daresay, there is a very, very large market for this - especially in Asia. I dont need the same for Word or Powerpoint - PDFs work fine in an emergency. For spreadsheets, I dont have an alternat…

Would you mind enumerating some of the most glaring omissions in existing Linux alternatives?

Re: LibreOffice 3.6.0: behind the scenes

#10
post #8

Will pay a lot of money for a Linux-compatible Excel feature-parity version of a spreadsheet. In fact, most spreadsheets today are created using OOXML, so it might be easier (notionally speaking) than the binary XLS format. I daresay, there is a very, very large market for this - especially in Asia. I dont need the same for Word or Powerpoint - PDFs work fine in an emergency. For spreadsheets, I dont have an alternat…

It's a tough thing to do -- particularly with Excel -- many spreadsheets include VBA code and other stuff that has dependencies on other parts of the Microsoft stack. OOXML is a beastly specification, because it's not just a description of how to create a document or spreadsheet -- it includes artifacts to maintain compatibility with MS Office software from the early 90's.

> OOXML is a beastly specification

Not to mention the various versions of it (e.g ECMA vs ISO, and their revisions) which led to differing and incompatible implementations, numerous areas where things are ambiguous or undefined, and things that are defined by referencing the undisclosed DOC/XLS spec.

Post reply on HN