Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Python GUI toolkits

news.ycombinator.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–8 of 8 posts

Ask HN: Python GUI toolkits

#1

Post by jftuga »

Since this was last asked on HN a few years ago, I thought I would ask again as things may have changed.

I am looking for a GUI toolkit for Python 3.2 that looks good on both Windows 7 and OS X. Here the catch: I am at best an average programmer so I need something really easy to use. My program will not be too complicated: I would just use listviews, buttons, text fields, etc. Is creating the GUI widgets via an XML file (along with the layout) a good way to go these days? It seems like this would be easier to develop and maintain.

Right now, I have a good command-line version of my program and want to add a GUI to it. I'd also love to "compile" the Python code and then be able to distribute it a .exe installer or a .dmg image.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Re: Ask HN: Python GUI toolkits

#2

Post by pendragon »

XML Doesn't necessarily make it easier. Maintaining and changing things down the road is better. wxPython doesn't have XML examples for every widget and it does make trying new things out more involved. wxPython isn't a pure MVC design. Hopefully a more expert developer will discuss this.

I would suggest looking at the most popular tookits and making an example screen with all the widgets you'll need in each and then testing it in OSX/Windows 7. Shouldn't take you too much time. Screen shots should filter the toolkits down to a reasonable number.

Another approach is to separate your presentation layer completely so that you can use different toolkits on each platform. With two platforms you'll only have to learn the basics of two libraries. If you move to Linux later this would allow you to use QT/GTK+ as well.

Re: Ask HN: Python GUI toolkits

#3

Post by wlesieutre »

Take a look at PySide. It's an alternative to PyQt with less restrictive licensing. You can use Qt Designer to visually edit GUIs, and then automatically produce the code for it using pyside-uic. I'm in a similar boat and just started looking at it recently, but it seems like a solid option. Nicer than Tkinter, I think.

http://www.pyside.org/

http://zetcode.com/gui/pysidetutorial/

Re: Ask HN: Python GUI toolkits

#4

Post by decadentcactus »

I've been using wxPython for a desktop client (tied to a website). Initially I tried to make it all by myself, then got a visual creator, and productivity went WAY up.

I used wxFormBuilder: http://sourceforge.net/projects/wxformbuilder/

It's pretty much a point-and-click sort of thing, but after the initial drafting/mockups I tweaked it by hand (small things like names/strings, as well as adding the events). I used Python 2.7 - not sure about 3.2.

If you need any help send me an email and I'll do my best to help. I've managed to compile/run it on Windows ok, and as far as I'm aware it's possible to compile it for Mac/Linux. I just have no Mac to test.

Re: Ask HN: Python GUI toolkits

#6

Post by arocks »

decadentcactus wrote: post #4

I've been using wxPython for a desktop client (tied to a website). Initially I tried to make it all by myself, then got a visual creator, and productivity went WAY up. I used wxFormBuilder: http://sourceforge.net/projects/wxformbuilder/ It's pretty much a point-and-click sort of thing, but after the initial drafting/mockups I tweaked it by hand (small things like names/strings, as well as adding the events). I used P…

After comparing a lot of cross-platform GUI toolkits in Python, I too settled on wxPython because it gives the closest possible 'native' experience on each platform. It also worked well with Py2EXE and other packaging tools. Would highly recommend that you give it a try.

Re: Ask HN: Python GUI toolkits

#7

Post by jftuga »

Thanks for all of the comments. I'll be checking out both PySide and wxPython ( and wxFormBuilder ).

However, from the PySide web page, "There are no PySide core developers using Windows or Mac and no more PySide build bots, so if you really want to see PySide running on those platforms better you do something."

Post reply on HN