Live data from Hacker News

Claude for Desktop

claude.ai

1–10 of 223 posts

Re: Claude for Desktop

#3

can someone tell me what the difference is to the webclient? Seems like a webview to me. No local caching/store.

Kids these days insist that they need the "app" of something, even when it's literally the exact same thing as the webpage.

Between this phenomenon and the refusal of many to close tabs in their browsers, I can't help but wonder if a huge percentage of the populace have never heard of or used Bookmarks on their web browsers before.

Re: Claude for Desktop

#6

can someone tell me what the difference is to the webclient? Seems like a webview to me. No local caching/store.

Kids these days insist that they need the "app" of something, even when it's literally the exact same thing as the webpage. Between this phenomenon and the refusal of many to close tabs in their browsers, I can't help but wonder if a huge percentage of the populace have never heard of or used Bookmarks on their web browsers before.

I think it’s less about not knowing what a bookmark is and more about just having a more direct way to access it, where it’s more high-level than just in a tab. There’s just something mentally different about opening a program from your dock as opposed to from a tab, even if they’re both basically a website.

Re: Claude for Desktop

#7

can someone tell me what the difference is to the webclient? Seems like a webview to me. No local caching/store.

From what I can tell you're right, it's essentially a web front end made to compete with ChatGPT's desktop app.

The only real benefit is the hotkey (ctrl + alt + space) for starting a new prompt when the window is closed, but still running in the background.

Re: Claude for Desktop

#8

can someone tell me what the difference is to the webclient? Seems like a webview to me. No local caching/store.

Kids these days insist that they need the "app" of something, even when it's literally the exact same thing as the webpage. Between this phenomenon and the refusal of many to close tabs in their browsers, I can't help but wonder if a huge percentage of the populace have never heard of or used Bookmarks on their web browsers before.

Having a hotkey to access the app removes a lot of friction

Re: Claude for Desktop

#9
post #7

can someone tell me what the difference is to the webclient? Seems like a webview to me. No local caching/store.

From what I can tell you're right, it's essentially a web front end made to compete with ChatGPT's desktop app. The only real benefit is the hotkey (ctrl + alt + space) for starting a new prompt when the window is closed, but still running in the background.

chatgpt has that shortcut too.

option + space for mac, and alt + space for windows.

Post reply on HN