Live data from Hacker News

Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

snats.xyz

1–10 of 117 posts

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#2
Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one. Not sure how representative it is of "the whole internet".

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#3
post #2

Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one.…

Doesn't sound like a lot, but where I am now we routinely work on very large infrastructure projects and the plans, documents and stuff mostly come as PDF. We are talking of thousands of documents, often with thousands of pages, per project and even very big projects almost never break 20 GB.

If you like, you could say, PDF are information dense, but data sparse. After all it is mostly white space ;)

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#4
post #2

Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one.…

Libgen size is ~33TB so, no, it's not "the largest corpus of PDFs online".

(Although you could argue libgen is not really "public" in the legal sense of the word, lol).

Disregarding that, the article is great!

(edit: why would someone downvote this, HN is becoming quite hostile lately)

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#5
post #2

Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one.…

Yeah 8TB is really tiny. Google scholar was estimated to index 160.000.000 pdfs in 2015.[0] If we assume that a third of those are not behind paywalls, and average pdf size is 1mb, its ends up as something above 50TB of documents. Almost ten years later the number of available pdfs of just scholarly communication should be substantially higher.

[0] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11192-015-1614-6

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#6
post #2

Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one.…

Is it possible that the 8 TB is just the extracted text?

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#7
post #2

Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one.…

Doesn't sound like a lot, but where I am now we routinely work on very large infrastructure projects and the plans, documents and stuff mostly come as PDF. We are talking of thousands of documents, often with thousands of pages, per project and even very big projects almost never break 20 GB. If you like, you could say, PDF are information dense, but data sparse. After all it is mostly white space ;)

They often aren't like you're describing, though. For example, pdfs with high res images embedded that are drafts of future book or pamphlets prints. These can be hundreds of Mbs for a single pdf with less than 100 pages, and are so common in marketing departments that it's hard to imagine that you could fit anywhere close to all the pdfs on 8TB.

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#8
post #2

Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one.…

>I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days

For those of us who aren't familiar with this random acronym, I think RTBF = right to be forgotten.

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#9
post #2

Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one.…

Libgen size is ~33TB so, no, it's not "the largest corpus of PDFs online". (Although you could argue libgen is not really "public" in the legal sense of the word, lol). Disregarding that, the article is great! (edit: why would someone downvote this, HN is becoming quite hostile lately)

8TB - ~8,000GB - is more than 33GB.

Re: Classifying all of the pdfs on the internet

#10
post #6
post #2

Interesting read, I did not know about Common Crawl. I feel like RTBF is kind of a lost battle these days with more and more crawlers for AI and whatnot. Once on the internet there is no way back, for better or for worse. This tangent aside, 8TB is really not a lot of data, it's just 8 consumer-grade 1TB hard drives. I find it hard to believe this is "the largest corpus of PDFs online", maybe the largest public one.…

Is it possible that the 8 TB is just the extracted text?

No, the Safedocs dataset is unprocessed pdfs.
Post reply on HN