Live data from Hacker News

Sorry, Young Man, You're Not the Most Important Demographic in Tech

theatlantic.com

1–10 of 53 posts

Re: Sorry, Young Man, You're Not the Most Important Demographic in Tech

#2
No evidence is presented that women are the more valuable market, just that on average they spend more time online and using their devices. Which would you pick: 10 customers that use a mobile phone for 20 hours each vs. 100 customers that use a mobile phone for 3 hours each?

No statistics are posted on how much male usage counts for, saying 17 percent more is a big difference when 100% is 4 hours vs. 40 hours.

> One huge reason is the relative lack of women at major venture capital firms, startups, electronics makers, and Internet companies.

This seems like a strange conclusion, the obvious conclusion is that on average 1 18 - 24 Male (the "most valuable demographic") is more likely to spend money with the advertiser after seeing advertising than a female counterpart, isn't it? They present no evidence disproving the obvious conclusion. I also don't see how tech adoption can be that important to a company like Apple. Maybe if it's 25% more likely a female that owns an iPhone will recommend to a friend and have them purchase it and the chances of a female purchasing vs. a male based on an advert is equal then sure, but if a male is 10x more likely to buy after seeing an advert what value is women causing "adoption", isn't people buying your products adoption?

Not a very good article. I would suggest it's just written to fit the narrative ("not enough women in tech") or it's just really badly written: you can't make assertions without proving them.

Sales = adoption.

Re: Sorry, Young Man, You're Not the Most Important Demographic in Tech

#3
"A young man contemplating his decreasing significance on the world stage" ...hilarious.

There's some truth in this. And it's what often concerns me about the tech world- that it's a big echo chamber of young, tech savvy people that actually represents a tiny demographic. It's one of the reasons I like living in New York- it gives me perspective. I see hundreds of people that are using 'dumbphones' and are quite happy with them. I know I've been reading too much TechCrunch when my friends who work in fashion, media, finance- anything but tech- tell me to shut the hell up.

"Path? What's that? A social network that limits how many friends I can have? Why the hell would I use that?". Sometimes it's good to be exposed to a little cynicism in life.

Re: Sorry, Young Man, You're Not the Most Important Demographic in Tech

#6
"there are clear business reasons for technology companies to focus their efforts on women. But few do."

Well, for example I am creating a writers' tool (basically a markdown editor). I wonder if there is anything in the product design with which I can target man/woman. I was thinking in terms of ease of use, intuitivnes, efficiency, etc...

I am thinkging in terms of power users / casual users, geeks / non-geeks, etc... but should I think in terms of women / men?

The article says Asus has sexist tweets... Wouldn't it be sexist if I had prejudices about women's use of a 'word processor'? I am not cynical, I genuinely ask this.

Re: Sorry, Young Man, You're Not the Most Important Demographic in Tech

#7

No evidence is presented that women are the more valuable market, just that on average they spend more time online and using their devices. Which would you pick: 10 customers that use a mobile phone for 20 hours each vs. 100 customers that use a mobile phone for 3 hours each? No statistics are posted on how much male usage counts for, saying 17 percent more is a big difference when 100% is 4 hours vs. 40 hours. > One…

"No evidence is presented that women are the more valuable market, just that on average they spend more time online and using their devices."

Perhaps that's because the evidence has already been stated clearly?

Here are the stats:

"Women account for $7 trillion in consumer and business spending in the United States, and over the next decade, they will control two thirds of consumer wealth.

Women make or influence 85% of all purchasing decisions, and purchase over 50% of traditional male products, including automobiles, home improvement products and consumer electronics.

BUT 91% of women say that advertisers don’t understand them."

(via http://thenextweb.com/socialmedia/2012/01/24/the-top-30-stat... )

Post reply on HN