Live data from Hacker News

Google Console closed testing requirements are awful

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 52 posts

Google Console closed testing requirements are awful

#1
I have been coding for 2-3 years and decided to make my first mobile app, just something small and simple to get a feel for it.

I wanted to publish it to the play store, get exposure and share what I have made. I paid the $25 fee, submitted my passport and bank statements for ID verification, and started the process to get my app published.

Well, what a terrible experience. It is not user friendly at all, and the requirement of 20 testers opting in to your closed testing for 14 days makes very little sense. I have spent the last few days messaging people, doing the test swaps, and generally wasting my time.

I have seen, from searching to find places that I can recruit testers, a number of 'services' where you can simply pay to have your app 'tested'. The whole thing has been really off-putting, what is the point..?

I wanted to make a flutter app next, something more detailed and complex.. but I am dreading having to go through this process of 'closed testing', after spending months making a project, essentially spamming forums and chat groups for testers. I paid for access to the store, I submitted my ID documents, this arbitrary barrier is so frustrating and again, really puts me off making a mobile app..

I know I am shouting into the void here, I suppose I just wanted to vent.

Re: Google Console closed testing requirements are awful

#3
post #2

It's a dumb & very counter-productive policy and will choke off the supply of new Android devs. Ironically it's now much easier to launch a new app on the Apple App Store than it is on Android.

Apple has its own unnecessary hurdles. Mostly around requiring xcode, which requires a mac.

But yeah, both stores need to be forcefully opened. They're sitting on their laurels inside their moats.

Re: Google Console closed testing requirements are awful

#4
They are crowdsourcing the effort of app moderation to save money. I have had many apps in different accounts and they just come up with any excuse pulled from their policies to bring them down and stop providing the service those $25 paid for. So they want to become hostile to developers? Fine, good riddance for the app store. Let's not waste our time and move to the web.

Re: Google Console closed testing requirements are awful

#6
post #3
post #2

It's a dumb & very counter-productive policy and will choke off the supply of new Android devs. Ironically it's now much easier to launch a new app on the Apple App Store than it is on Android.

Apple has its own unnecessary hurdles. Mostly around requiring xcode, which requires a mac. But yeah, both stores need to be forcefully opened. They're sitting on their laurels inside their moats.

The XCode requirement makes some sense because it would take Apple a lot of extra work to port and support their tools on other platforms. Work that they have no incentive to do.

But I think the native app market in general has peaked. Most things can be done in a web app now.

Re: Google Console closed testing requirements are awful

#9
Starting ~2021 the most important Android execs got it in their heads that no one in Android was testing software because they were finding and reporting bugs, even late in release cycles.

It was like that famous bomber with bullet holes diagram, the part they were missing was the bugs were being reported, it was just only theirs were being taken seriously, and the rest were treated as annoyances*

Funnily enough, it actually made the culture exponentially worse because it layered on tons of process and paperwork, which gave more ammo to the actual problem, clique-y and unhealthy coddling of us vs. them behavior within the clique, which also drove a lot of people outside it to stop thinking they could help make things better, and if they did, it didn't/wouldn't matter anyway.

I always think of that whenever I shudder about this nonsense. Partly because the same leadership that was too nice & added testing + paperwork eyewash to fix a people problem, added testing + paperwork eyewash here.

When you have a hammer...

Re: Google Console closed testing requirements are awful

#10
post #3
post #2

It's a dumb & very counter-productive policy and will choke off the supply of new Android devs. Ironically it's now much easier to launch a new app on the Apple App Store than it is on Android.

Apple has its own unnecessary hurdles. Mostly around requiring xcode, which requires a mac. But yeah, both stores need to be forcefully opened. They're sitting on their laurels inside their moats.

I've just been using the MacOS runner in Github Actions. Still requires the $99/year fee but not the $2000 laptop.
Post reply on HN