Live data from Hacker News

The Earth is getting greener

vox.com

1–10 of 180 posts

Re: The Earth is getting greener

#2
> industrial cropland typically produces more carbon emissions than it absorbs over the long term

Question about this: where does the extra carbon it emits come from? Is it already in the land beforehand?

Re: The Earth is getting greener

#3
post #2

> industrial cropland typically produces more carbon emissions than it absorbs over the long term Question about this: where does the extra carbon it emits come from? Is it already in the land beforehand?

From trucks coming to and from fields?

Re: The Earth is getting greener

#6
post #5

[flagged]

> propagandists advancing world views detached from any empirical or rational belief

The linked article is entirely empirical, and frankly seems like a good explainer for the lay public to understand what's happening. Your post seems a little like a strawman. Are you arguing against anything in particular?

Re: The Earth is getting greener

#7
post #2

> industrial cropland typically produces more carbon emissions than it absorbs over the long term Question about this: where does the extra carbon it emits come from? Is it already in the land beforehand?

I believe Vox slightly screwed this up but it's an understandable mistake: the article[1] refers to CO2 equivalent of emissions, not literal CO2. In particular methane from fertilizers seems to have a more negative impact on overall greenhouse gases than whatever CO2 the plants are absorbing.

[1] https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/acd5e8

Re: The Earth is getting greener

#8
post #5

[flagged]

Except the rate of change in CO2 is far exceeding the rate of change of any compensatory process, and the replacement of natural plant growth with crops leads to excess methane release that more than compensates for the reduced CO2, so yeah. It’s not surprising, but it’s also insufficient.

Re: The Earth is getting greener

#10
post #2

> industrial cropland typically produces more carbon emissions than it absorbs over the long term Question about this: where does the extra carbon it emits come from? Is it already in the land beforehand?

Petro chemical based fertilizer and gas powered equipment.
Post reply on HN