Live data from Hacker News

Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, Fail-Upward Brunchlords

techdirt.com

1–10 of 81 posts

Re: Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, Fail-Upward Brunchlords

#6
Kissinger's death was where I really started detaching myself from news media entirely. It was extremely hard to find an article or video that didn't say the exact same thing in almost identical wording: "was kissinger a war criminal? well he was certainly controversial but his influence stood large". No, objectively, he was a war criminal. Bombing Cambodia and several other actions were, factually, legally, war crimes. There's no way to two sides it.

Even though I'd firmly disagree with it, I'd much rather read an article that says "yeah, he was a war criminal, but war crimes are okay when America does them because America good." Instead you get this washed out nothingness where we as a society can't reflect on anything.

It Reminds me of the scene in the Big Short where they're trying to convince the reporter to run the story on the obvious pump And dump, and the guys like "hey I've got a family to feed."

Re: Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, Fail-Upward Brunchlords

#7
These people took glee in demonizing and dehumanizing half of the country under the guise they're on the wrong side of history. Except what actually happened is the pendulum has swung in the other direction completely repudiating credibility of these organizations, and the people that were dehumanized are understandably very mad.

These alleged journalists are supposed to report on the the world and events around them, except they refuse to see what's in front of them because it's inconvenient to their failed idealogical positions.

Re: Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, Fail-Upward Brunchlords

#8
What a callous article. It seems the author is angry that a bunch of people came together to fund a company that failed in the end...well, most startups fail anyway.

> Such journalism is a direct reflection of millionaire or billionaire media owners who don’t want to offend sources, advertisers, or event sponsors with bold, truth-telling journalism that has actual teeth. So what you get instead is a sort of journalism simulacrum that fails to critique wealth, corruption, or power with any real consistency, since the wealthy and powerful owners very obviously don’t want that.

If you want to start an activist site, go start one and solicit donations from your rage-baited audience (that's what Techdirt is afterall). The Messenger didn't claim and never wanted to be an investigative news outlet. It was a simple news outlet that churned out everyday news without giving opinions..I actually loved it!

The sheer arrogance of some journalists...and they wonder why their industry is on a massive decline.

Re: Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, Fail-Upward Brunchlords

#9

Examples in there of employee healthcare woes... sure with we just had universal healthcare.

>sure with we just had universal healthcare.

I dropped out of medical school over a decade ago, so my opinion is absolutely jaded. Talking with graduate physicians, the general concensus is "universal healthcare will never happen in the US." So my suggestion to unencumbered youngins is to study/travel abroad, and begin your expatriation quest... OR: become an attorney (joke: "in the US, for a cancer diagnosis, the best outcome is to be a lawyer").

Re: Messenger Implosion Shows Journalism Lead by Visionless, Fail-Upward Brunchlords

#10

These people took glee in demonizing and dehumanizing half of the country under the guise they're on the wrong side of history. Except what actually happened is the pendulum has swung in the other direction completely repudiating credibility of these organizations, and the people that were dehumanized are understandably very mad. These alleged journalists are supposed to report on the the world and events around them…

Absolutely, it is great that the article writer is no longer employed as a journalist
Post reply on HN