Live data from Hacker News

Can you make yourself smarter?

nytimes.com

1–10 of 55 posts

Re: Can you make yourself smarter?

#2
Not yet HN ready and I wanted to post this later . I have been working on a HTML 5 implementation , If you want to try the tasks mentioned.

http://alpha.brainturk.com

the chein task can be found here http://alpha.brainturk.com/chein

Please let me know your suggestions on how to improve this . I need to make a few more changes for this to be played on ipad but for now works with the keyboard

Re: Can you make yourself smarter?

#4
When learning to program, my first major project was a feature-loaded N-back in C#/XNA. I crammed in every option I could think of. The game and code is available at http://workingmemoryworkout.codeplex.com, and it's worth noting that the inspiration came from Brain Workshop. (http://brainworkshop.sourceforge.net/)

Re: Can you make yourself smarter?

#5
post #3

from the article, one of the games is http://www.soakyourhead.com/dual-n-back.aspx update: You need a speaker to play should say "Press A when the box appears in the same location _since the start of the game_"

FYI: requires Silverlight.

Re: Can you make yourself smarter?

#6
The scientific evidence for Dual N Back improving fluid intelligence is actually fairly weak as far as I can tell, see this critique and the other studies discussed:

http://www.gwern.net/DNB%20FAQ#criticism

My personal theory is that solving difficult math and programming problems is a better use of time than doing working memory training exercises. I'd guess that solving math and programming problems improve working memory just as fast as playing 'brain games', and they have the additional benefit of improving one's math and programming skill.

Of course, this is just a guess of mine that is unsupported by any experimental evidence.

Re: Can you make yourself smarter?

#8

The scientific evidence for Dual N Back improving fluid intelligence is actually fairly weak as far as I can tell, see this critique and the other studies discussed: http://www.gwern.net/DNB%20FAQ#criticism My personal theory is that solving difficult math and programming problems is a better use of time than doing working memory training exercises. I'd guess that solving math and programming problems improve working…

In this book http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0141035501/ the author says that solving simple math equations (addition,subtraction ,division) fast is much more stimulating than doing complex math.

Re: Can you make yourself smarter?

#9
Wow, the timing here seems auspicious.

Lately I've been thinking about the limitations that being human puts on a programmer. We work very hard (and should) to reduce cognitive load on ourselves through good development tools that act as crutches for memory---REPL's and good debuggers allow us to try something and see what happens, as opposed to simulating a multivariate operation in our heads. Intellisense and easily-available docs allow us to cheat a bit on learning(and what I really mean is memorizing) API's.

But what if we could do these things without relying on JIT computer aids? What if I could simulate more levels of abstraction in my head? The private dream of many a Lisper(this one, anyway)---writing programs that write programs that write programs---would be a bit more attainable.

I've been using Anki with great success to learn API's and keyboard shortcuts (Anki+emacs is a match made in heaven), but I despaired at my inability to hold the whole stack, from top to bottom, in my head at once. So I posted a badly phrased question on Stack Exchange, ("How can I increase the number of levels of abstraction I can reason about at once?), and kept Googling. Eventually I came across Jaeggi's research. It looks promising, but hasn't passed the wide-replication test yet. I'm glad this came up on HN, because I'm eager to see more research in the area and get come confirmation or refutation of the findings.

In the meantime, the premise of Jaeggi's conclusion raises two questions---if working memory can be trained, can it decay with disuse? In that case, are with our fancy debugging tools mere shadows of Real Programmers that used to walk the earth? The other question is this---if the brain is likened to a computer, working memory corresponds to RAM. If we are successful at training working memory and making people "smarter," will we in the future face a bottleneck of processing speed rather than space?

Re: Can you make yourself smarter?

#10
post #2

Not yet HN ready and I wanted to post this later . I have been working on a HTML 5 implementation , If you want to try the tasks mentioned. http://alpha.brainturk.com the chein task can be found here http://alpha.brainturk.com/chein Please let me know your suggestions on how to improve this . I need to make a few more changes for this to be played on ipad but for now works with the keyboard

the Nback Progress page doesn't appear to be working
Post reply on HN