Live data from Hacker News

1,626 Books Were Banned Across America Last Year We Reviewed All of Them

yarn.joinstatecraft.com

1–10 of 99 posts

Re: 1,626 Books Were Banned Across America Last Year We Reviewed All of Them

#3
Book banning seems like a strange red line to have forgotten. If your kid is going to be corrupted by going into a library and finding a book that's naughtier than your taste, they're probably ahead of their similarly-corruptible peers who aren't in a library at all.

Re: 1,626 Books Were Banned Across America Last Year We Reviewed All of Them

#5

Book banning seems like a strange red line to have forgotten. If your kid is going to be corrupted by going into a library and finding a book that's naughtier than your taste, they're probably ahead of their similarly-corruptible peers who aren't in a library at all.

[flagged]

Re: 1,626 Books Were Banned Across America Last Year We Reviewed All of Them

#7
> it’s important to note that they are to the end of positive social change

The end does not justify the means. Name me one single objectively bad political movement which internally thought of themselves as bad or negative. There isn't one. They all claim and for the largest part of their membership believe to serve the greater good. Therefore I find this argument of the author extremely weak. Surely they can come up with some less naive arguments?

Re: 1,626 Books Were Banned Across America Last Year We Reviewed All of Them

#8

Book banning seems like a strange red line to have forgotten. If your kid is going to be corrupted by going into a library and finding a book that's naughtier than your taste, they're probably ahead of their similarly-corruptible peers who aren't in a library at all.

I'm not in favor of banning books, but "it's not the worst thing that could possibly happen" isn't exactly a strong argument for supporting something.
Post reply on HN