Live data from Hacker News

Europe: Is compulsory military service coming back?

dw.com

1–10 of 128 posts

Re: Europe: Is compulsory military service coming back?

#2
> The United Kingdom, the United States and Canada have had exclusively professional armies for 50 years or more.

One idea would be for the EU, instead of individual member states, to stand up a professional army. Then you don't have to force people and it also just might bind European countries more closely together.

Re: Europe: Is compulsory military service coming back?

#3
The obvious question to me is are they arming to defend themselves from Russia or from other European nations rearming? Russia struggled against Ukraine so it seems unlikely that they'd fare well against a country with a similar GDP.

Sardonic congratulations to the fine minds at NATO for manoeuvring us towards this outcome. Anyone who feels optimistic as all these armies limber up is beyond an idiot. As a culture we've missed several decades of opportunities to de-fuse this situation.

I hope all this is a short spark that goes away.

Re: Europe: Is compulsory military service coming back?

#5

> The United Kingdom, the United States and Canada have had exclusively professional armies for 50 years or more. One idea would be for the EU, instead of individual member states, to stand up a professional army. Then you don't have to force people and it also just might bind European countries more closely together.

European Union is not a sovereign entity that can have its 'own' military.

Re: Europe: Is compulsory military service coming back?

#9
post #5

> The United Kingdom, the United States and Canada have had exclusively professional armies for 50 years or more. One idea would be for the EU, instead of individual member states, to stand up a professional army. Then you don't have to force people and it also just might bind European countries more closely together.

European Union is not a sovereign entity that can have its 'own' military.

> European Union is not a sovereign entity that can have its 'own' military.

From a cursory read, it doesn't seem like that stands in the way: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_army

Re: Europe: Is compulsory military service coming back?

#10
post #5

> The United Kingdom, the United States and Canada have had exclusively professional armies for 50 years or more. One idea would be for the EU, instead of individual member states, to stand up a professional army. Then you don't have to force people and it also just might bind European countries more closely together.

European Union is not a sovereign entity that can have its 'own' military.

That’s true, but there has been discussions about it for at least twenty years. Will it ever materialize? Dunno.
Post reply on HN