Live data from Hacker News

What's the Difference Between Empathy, Sympathy, and Compassion?

chopra.com

1–10 of 72 posts

Re: What's the Difference Between Empathy, Sympathy, and Compassion?

#2
This isn't a bad piece, but it somewhat oversimplifies these concepts. For example, "compathy" is more directly "viscerally feeling what another feels" while "empathy" is more accurately defined as the intellectual or emotional capacity for engaging in compathy. That capacity can be grounded in actually feeling what the observed other feels -- which, arguably, is impossible if the observed is experiencing something the observer has no shared personal experience with -- or by feeling what an observer imagines the observer would feel if sharing the personal experience of an observed. Actual empathy _requires_ that one is "able to understand what the person is feeling" -- which is what this piece uses as the (somewhat imprecise) definition of "sympathy".

Similarly, "sympathy" is more accurately defined as "(the expression of) understanding of what the person is feeling" ... one need not actually understand the feelings of another to engage in sympathy (ie, most sympathy does not require actual empathy, but actual sympathy does require actual empathy), and often actual compassion (which derives from actual empathy) requires one to not engage in actual sympathy.

Nevertheless, good to see an attempt to unpack these terms.

> “If you want others to be happy, practice compassion. If you want to be happy, practice compassion.”

... and try to recognize that what is desired, but not attained (happiness) is not as important or impactful as what is practiced, but not mastered (compassion).

Re: What's the Difference Between Empathy, Sympathy, and Compassion?

#3
post #2

This isn't a bad piece, but it somewhat oversimplifies these concepts. For example, "compathy" is more directly "viscerally feeling what another feels" while "empathy" is more accurately defined as the intellectual or emotional capacity for engaging in compathy. That capacity can be grounded in actually feeling what the observed other feels -- which, arguably, is impossible if the observed is experiencing something t…

Sympathy literally means "feeling together".

Re: What's the Difference Between Empathy, Sympathy, and Compassion?

#4
post #2

This isn't a bad piece, but it somewhat oversimplifies these concepts. For example, "compathy" is more directly "viscerally feeling what another feels" while "empathy" is more accurately defined as the intellectual or emotional capacity for engaging in compathy. That capacity can be grounded in actually feeling what the observed other feels -- which, arguably, is impossible if the observed is experiencing something t…

There are a frustrating number of conflicting definitions of all three (compassion, sympathy, empathy) terms but I share your definitions.

    and often actual compassion (which derives from 
    actual empathy) requires one to not engage in actual 
    sympathy.
I think this is a great insight. For example, in order to care for somebody compassionately in a medical setting, a doctor or caregiver might at times need to actually shut off their sympathy and/or empathy so that they can perform compassionate acts.

Example: a doctor or nurse performing the excruciating treatments needed by a burn victim. Especially one who is too young or incapacitated to know what's happening. One imagines you'd need to temporarily shut off one's sympathy and empathy in order to perform the care which is ultimately going to be the most compassionate thing in the long run.

Re: What's the Difference Between Empathy, Sympathy, and Compassion?

#6
I'm not particularly religious these days, but I was raised a Christian. When I was around 10 learning about the ideas behind empathy, sympathy and compassion this song always came to mind[1].

I think compassion is doing something with your empathy and sympathy. I think compassion is really important, more people should "cross over the road".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PCP5gHlasf8

Re: What's the Difference Between Empathy, Sympathy, and Compassion?

#8

12 year old me playing D&D: "What is the purpose of having separate intelligence and wisdom stats? They are the same thing!" Older me: "Oh."

They'll find out it's really not, when they inevitably meet a foolish highly-intelligent person doing unwise things...

Re: What's the Difference Between Empathy, Sympathy, and Compassion?

#9
Empathy deals with the emotional systems (I feel you). Sympathy deals with intellectual (I understand what you feel or imagine it must feel like x). Compassion is a transcendent experience in which you try to imagine yourself in the shoes of another.

Re: What's the Difference Between Empathy, Sympathy, and Compassion?

#10

12 year old me playing D&D: "What is the purpose of having separate intelligence and wisdom stats? They are the same thing!" Older me: "Oh."

Intelligence: Here is how you can remove this fence.

Wisdom: Should we really be removing this fence?

Post reply on HN