Live data from Hacker News

Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

whydoeseverythingsuck.com

1–10 of 22 posts

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#2
Accurate or not, that's a pretty good idea. Being able to detach the screen and plug the computer into a bigger monitor would suit perfectly the way I use my laptop at the moment.

Plus, with the screen removed the "brick" is presumably a computer in a keyboard form factor, just like in the good old days.

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#3
post #2

Accurate or not, that's a pretty good idea. Being able to detach the screen and plug the computer into a bigger monitor would suit perfectly the way I use my laptop at the moment. Plus, with the screen removed the "brick" is presumably a computer in a keyboard form factor, just like in the good old days.

I don't get it. I plug a bigger monitor to my laptop when I'm at my desk. Why the need to detach the laptop screen?

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#4
post #2

Accurate or not, that's a pretty good idea. Being able to detach the screen and plug the computer into a bigger monitor would suit perfectly the way I use my laptop at the moment. Plus, with the screen removed the "brick" is presumably a computer in a keyboard form factor, just like in the good old days.

Why bother detaching the screen? Close the lid and put it on a dock.

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#5
post #3
post #2

Accurate or not, that's a pretty good idea. Being able to detach the screen and plug the computer into a bigger monitor would suit perfectly the way I use my laptop at the moment. Plus, with the screen removed the "brick" is presumably a computer in a keyboard form factor, just like in the good old days.

I don't get it. I plug a bigger monitor to my laptop when I'm at my desk. Why the need to detach the laptop screen?

same here. and I know some use there laptop screen as a second monitor. so this is a bad idea on many fronts.

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#6
post #4
post #2

Accurate or not, that's a pretty good idea. Being able to detach the screen and plug the computer into a bigger monitor would suit perfectly the way I use my laptop at the moment. Plus, with the screen removed the "brick" is presumably a computer in a keyboard form factor, just like in the good old days.

Why bother detaching the screen? Close the lid and put it on a dock.

That's what I do now (except for the dock, I just plug everything in) but if I had one of these I could save: (a) on buying a separate keyboard and (b) on desk space.

OK, it's not a huge advantage, but it's neat.

Only downside: unless they're very clever with the design, a brick-keyboard isn't as good to type on as a regular keyboard. But hey, maybe they'll be clever with the design, so it tilts downwards properly.

Hmm, and I just thought of another nice way to use it: on my lap, on the couch, plugged into my big-ass TV.

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#7
post #2

Accurate or not, that's a pretty good idea. Being able to detach the screen and plug the computer into a bigger monitor would suit perfectly the way I use my laptop at the moment. Plus, with the screen removed the "brick" is presumably a computer in a keyboard form factor, just like in the good old days.

A detaching laptop screen seems unlikely. The mechanical stresses on the attachment device sound too extreme.

This also sounds like a new series of monitors which Apple probably won't do until they can have LED backlights in the big screens.

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#8
post #3
post #2

Accurate or not, that's a pretty good idea. Being able to detach the screen and plug the computer into a bigger monitor would suit perfectly the way I use my laptop at the moment. Plus, with the screen removed the "brick" is presumably a computer in a keyboard form factor, just like in the good old days.

I don't get it. I plug a bigger monitor to my laptop when I'm at my desk. Why the need to detach the laptop screen?

I'm not expecting this to actually happen... but I would instantly buy a Mac laptop that let me physically separate the screen and the keyboard while continuing to use them both. Then I could set the screen up on a portable stand at approximately the right height and distance while the keyboard lived closer to me and lower down, perhaps even in my lap.

Right now the best I can do is to carry an external keyboard. But it's a pain to have to tote around redundant hardware. Of course, it's also a pain to be in pain after spending too much time using an un-ergonomic laptop.

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#9

  * Sounds clunky, and overspecialized.
  * Awkwardly splits the product (display/no display).
  * Competes with the low-end Macbook, while being a lower-margin product.
  * Can't imagine a design for this that isn't ugly.
Very Un-Apple. Jobs isn't going to follow up the iPhone 3G with this, aptly described, 'brick'.

Re: Did Some Insider Just Spill The Beans On New Apple Laptop?

#10
post #6
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why bother detaching the screen? Close the lid and put it on a dock.

That's what I do now (except for the dock, I just plug everything in) but if I had one of these I could save: (a) on buying a separate keyboard and (b) on desk space. OK, it's not a huge advantage, but it's neat. Only downside: unless they're very clever with the design, a brick-keyboard isn't as good to type on as a regular keyboard. But hey, maybe they'll be clever with the design, so it tilts downwards properly. H…

Better yet, transmitting the video output to your TV.
Post reply on HN