Live data from Hacker News

Tim Cook's fix for those pesky green text bubbles? 'Buy your mom an iPhone'

text.npr.org

1–10 of 15 posts

Re: Tim Cook's fix for those pesky green text bubbles? 'Buy your mom an iPhone'

#4
When you see this topic discussed, invariably iPhone users chime in to say the exact same thing. They like the status symbol and have come to identify with it, even though it results in a worse experience for them. The internet is built on open standards, but Apple has convinced its users that closed services are elite.

Re: Tim Cook's fix for those pesky green text bubbles? 'Buy your mom an iPhone'

#6

Spoken like a true cult leader. They want the color of a chat bubble to become associated with status. How long before they advocate for a caste system in America based on whether you own Apple devices.

That's literally their policy with iMessage.

Re: Tim Cook's fix for those pesky green text bubbles? 'Buy your mom an iPhone'

#7

Spoken like a true cult leader. They want the color of a chat bubble to become associated with status. How long before they advocate for a caste system in America based on whether you own Apple devices.

There already is one here. Many low income people don’t own iPhones. iPhone isn’t a popular or accessible choice or typically associated with prepaid cell phone providers, and if it’s available, it’s ridiculously overpriced at cell phone stores in disadvantaged communities.

That’s not on accident. Apple could, at this point, offer budget-friendly devices but they choose not to. Whenever they release a new device, it always comes in a few flavors —- all expensive.

What’s sad to me is not that most of the poor don’t own an iPhone, but the lengths I’ve seen some people go to buy one who can’t afford it, just in an effort to keep up.

It’s even worse at schools. I have a nephew who came home in tears because he was bullied for owning an Android, and begging his parents (who couldn’t afford it) to buy him an iPhone so he could fit in. When that happened, everything Apple instantly became unattractive to me; I never go into Apple stores anymore (no matter how cool the tech), and I stopped buying their products.

Of course, I think the sad part is there simply aren’t enough people like me to even move the needle enough to make Apple care, and that’s the real travesty.

Re: Tim Cook's fix for those pesky green text bubbles? 'Buy your mom an iPhone'

#8
post #5

I couldn't really figure out why US cellular users stayed on SMS and MMS while the rest of the world moved to WhatsApp or Telegram.

As a US cellular user, me neither. The only reason I can think of is that iPhone users are such a large portion of all US users, and this would effectively require convincing them to use something other than iMessages just to include Android users.

Re: Tim Cook's fix for those pesky green text bubbles? 'Buy your mom an iPhone'

#9
Why is this even an issue? The green bubble signifies an SMS/MMS message (or a non Apple Messages, message). I don’t think any non-Apple users are upset that their chat is in a green bubble as opposed to blue.

It would have been nice if an open replacement standard for SMS/MMS had been introduced as network bandwidth improved over the last two decades, but it didn’t and instead we have a bunch of competing messaging services sending through our phone data plans. I’ve got Telegram, WhatsApp, Messages, and Google Chat to handle all the simple text/image/video messages I get from various people, and none of them standout as particularly better, I just have friends or colleagues on one of them.

Re: Tim Cook's fix for those pesky green text bubbles? 'Buy your mom an iPhone'

#10

Spoken like a true cult leader. They want the color of a chat bubble to become associated with status. How long before they advocate for a caste system in America based on whether you own Apple devices.

There already is one here. Many low income people don’t own iPhones. iPhone isn’t a popular or accessible choice or typically associated with prepaid cell phone providers, and if it’s available, it’s ridiculously overpriced at cell phone stores in disadvantaged communities. That’s not on accident. Apple could, at this point, offer budget-friendly devices but they choose not to. Whenever they release a new device, it…

I agree with everything you’re saying. Isn’t the SE supposed to be a “budget” option though? I’m not someone who keeps up with this stuff though. Hopefully it can be a learning experience for your nephew about not worrying what others thing - just looking on the bright side, then when they’re older maybe they can have the perspective of “not being cool is cool in a way”.
Post reply on HN