Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Do you expect/want to see salary information in a job ad?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 33 posts

Poll: Do you expect/want to see salary information in a job ad?

#1
We are recruiting new engineers and having a discussion about whether to include salary information in job descriptions or not.

I would love to know what the general consensus and expectations of the HN crowd towards this issue is.

Many thanks and Happy Hacking.

Re: Poll: Do you expect/want to see salary information in a job ad?

#3
A reasonable range would absolutely be great but I understand why disclosing any salary information would be challenging for the company as it changes how compensation negotiation is done but will also affect the overall culture. Ultimately, you need to continue your first principles thinking and put this hypothesis to the test.

Re: Poll: Do you expect/want to see salary information in a job ad?

#5
post #3

A reasonable range would absolutely be great but I understand why disclosing any salary information would be challenging for the company as it changes how compensation negotiation is done but will also affect the overall culture. Ultimately, you need to continue your first principles thinking and put this hypothesis to the test.

> I understand why disclosing any salary information would be challenging for the company as it changes how compensation negotiation is done but will also affect the overall culture.

So do I, but I refuse to care. I'm not willing to jump through all of the hoops that come with interviewing for a tech job only to find myself having to say no because I'd be taking a pay cut.

My life matters, I'm not getting any younger, and I'm not willing to waste time for some corporation's convenience. I already have a solid job, and a decent network outside of LinkedIn in case I need to jump ship. Tech recruiters will deal with me on my terms or not at all.

Re: Poll: Do you expect/want to see salary information in a job ad?

#6

Has to be a tight range. Some recruiters try to give a non-sensical, meaningless range where the upper bound is close to 3x the lower bound.

How is that nonsensical? Lots of times, the same nominal job might involve vastly varying amounts of responsibility or productivity. I've seen positions where 3X dynamic range would be unreasonably small, e.g. at companies which don't bucket engineering roles into arbitrary seniority brackets.

Re: Poll: Do you expect/want to see salary information in a job ad?

#8
I've said it before and I'll say it again: if you can't be up-front about what you're going to pay a person for doing a job and offer the same to everybody, that's a red flag and it tells me you're looking to screw somebody. Tells me everything I need to know about you right there, and that's an instant hard-pass.

Should be legally required by federal law to post salary for any job ad regardless of platform of publication.

Re: Poll: Do you expect/want to see salary information in a job ad?

#9
Tech jobs vary wildly in pay, but their marketing language doesn't. This makes it very hard to know what's worth your time. The reality is, if you're making >$100k and a recruiter comes offering "a great opportunity to work at the next big thing!" but their top range is $90k, then there's almost no chance you'll choose to go there.

Since pay is paramount to the employment arrangement, why wouldn't I expect that to match up near the beginning?

I will add a small note: if a recruiter reaches out with a job that doesn't mention salary, I won't outright ignore it, but asking for a range is always in my first reply. If that isn't answered then things stop there.

Post reply on HN