Live data from Hacker News

Whitman Expected to Get HP CEO Nod After Markets Close

allthingsd.com

1–10 of 50 posts

Re: Whitman Expected to Get HP CEO Nod After Markets Close

#2
I have much respect for Meg Whitman, but she is not an ideal pick for HP. Her experience is with consumer companies -- eBay, P&G, Disney...Especially if HP spins off its PC business, that leaves the company as essentially a pure enterprise hardware/software play. Don't do it HP.

Re: Whitman Expected to Get HP CEO Nod After Markets Close

#5
There was an article I read about this yesterday on one of the big tech websites, I'm not sure which one. HP basically hired a guy that was good at something, and operated in a certain way, and now that he's doing it, they're firing him. Granted, not everything has been well-executed, but come on, its like buying a motorcycle and then returning it because it isn't air-conditioned.

Re: Whitman Expected to Get HP CEO Nod After Markets Close

#6

There was an article I read about this yesterday on one of the big tech websites, I'm not sure which one. HP basically hired a guy that was good at something, and operated in a certain way, and now that he's doing it, they're firing him. Granted, not everything has been well-executed, but come on, its like buying a motorcycle and then returning it because it isn't air-conditioned.

Really have to ponder why Whitman would take this job given the probability of being fired next year no matter what happens...

Re: Whitman Expected to Get HP CEO Nod After Markets Close

#9
During Whitman's gubernatorial campaign there was a great quote on SFGate, something like: "Meg Whitman is the only force in the universe that could compel me to vote for Jerry Brown." I felt the same way, pretty much.

I don't know much about her work at eBay, but the distant, autocratic way she ran her campaign -- she didn't get out and talk to people, she just stayed in her castle and put out ads -- strikes me as the antithesis of the management style needed by a company in crisis.

Post reply on HN