Live data from Hacker News

S.F. Mayor Breed declares state of emergency in the Tenderloin

sfchronicle.com

1–10 of 26 posts

Re: S.F. Mayor Breed declares state of emergency in the Tenderloin

#6
I really don't understand why this wasn't done years ago.

> is concerned that the emergency declaration is being used to support her plan for more policing in the neighborhood, which could criminalize people with substance use disorders before resources such as the supervised drug-use site or a planned drug sobering center open.

Honest question. Is a supervised drug-use site an effective approach for reducing drug use long term? Does it help get people into services that help them deal with addiction? Or is it just meant to supervise potential overdoes and intervene?

Re: S.F. Mayor Breed declares state of emergency in the Tenderloin

#7

I really don't understand why this wasn't done years ago. > is concerned that the emergency declaration is being used to support her plan for more policing in the neighborhood, which could criminalize people with substance use disorders before resources such as the supervised drug-use site or a planned drug sobering center open. Honest question. Is a supervised drug-use site an effective approach for reducing drug us…

Regan passed a bunch of bills as Governor that basically disbanded mental health care for the homeless.

Since it’s illegal to stick them in a drug rehab clinic, mandatory counseling sessions, or even force them back on their meds (with their prior written consent), all that’s left is putting them out of the public eye while they get high, I guess.

Or, maybe we could just switch the law back to what it was in 70’s.

Re: S.F. Mayor Breed declares state of emergency in the Tenderloin

#8
post #7

I really don't understand why this wasn't done years ago. > is concerned that the emergency declaration is being used to support her plan for more policing in the neighborhood, which could criminalize people with substance use disorders before resources such as the supervised drug-use site or a planned drug sobering center open. Honest question. Is a supervised drug-use site an effective approach for reducing drug us…

Regan passed a bunch of bills as Governor that basically disbanded mental health care for the homeless. Since it’s illegal to stick them in a drug rehab clinic, mandatory counseling sessions, or even force them back on their meds (with their prior written consent), all that’s left is putting them out of the public eye while they get high, I guess. Or, maybe we could just switch the law back to what it was in 70’s.

Were these law irrevocable? If not, every governor and state legislature since then are also complicit.

Re: S.F. Mayor Breed declares state of emergency in the Tenderloin

#9
It's great London Breed is acknowledging SF's policy flaws... but I hope SF gets a new-mayor that is genuine about fixing the city rather than keep the Mayor who has for years exacerbated these problems and only decided to do something now because it was politically expedient.

Re: S.F. Mayor Breed declares state of emergency in the Tenderloin

#10
post #7

I really don't understand why this wasn't done years ago. > is concerned that the emergency declaration is being used to support her plan for more policing in the neighborhood, which could criminalize people with substance use disorders before resources such as the supervised drug-use site or a planned drug sobering center open. Honest question. Is a supervised drug-use site an effective approach for reducing drug us…

Regan passed a bunch of bills as Governor that basically disbanded mental health care for the homeless. Since it’s illegal to stick them in a drug rehab clinic, mandatory counseling sessions, or even force them back on their meds (with their prior written consent), all that’s left is putting them out of the public eye while they get high, I guess. Or, maybe we could just switch the law back to what it was in 70’s.

> Regan

Reagan

> passed a bunch of bills as Governor

Governors don't unilaterally “pass bills”. They sign (or veto) bills passed by the legislator.

> that basically disbanded mental health care for the homeless.

Deinstitutionalization was a bipartisan, national phenomenon driven in large parts by abuse scandals in institutions.

Post reply on HN