Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What would it take for you to stop using Hacker News?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 51 posts

Re: Ask HN: What would it take for you to stop using Hacker News?

#6
The "downvote due to disagree" thing really annoys me. That and making the text become washed out. I hate it. Especially when I've seen excellent unpopular comments disappear because they were simply unpopular due to politics. Its anti-intellectual. I want to see unpopular comments because they often reveal something interesting.

People should be downvoting because its not appropriate intellectually (adds nothing, eg provides no evidence to back up a claim that obviously needs it). Flagging should be because it is simply inappropriate for usually offensive reasons.

I rarely comment now. I often don't see the point.

I've also often considered a tool to only provide the RSS feed for interesting article discovery then mostly ignore the comments completely. Comments on the ask/show sections are usually more signal than noise. Sometimes even the noise is interesting.

Upvotes should exist to make interesting content rise. Uninteresting content then simply sinks to the bottom.

But votes are a difficult problem to solve. I'm sure there are too many corner cases I've no idea about.

Re: Ask HN: What would it take for you to stop using Hacker News?

#9

The "downvote due to disagree" thing really annoys me. That and making the text become washed out. I hate it. Especially when I've seen excellent unpopular comments disappear because they were simply unpopular due to politics. Its anti-intellectual. I want to see unpopular comments because they often reveal something interesting. People should be downvoting because its not appropriate intellectually (adds nothing, eg…

>The "downvote due to disagree" thing really annoys me.

Absolutely. I agree with everything else you bring up as well.

I would love to see down-voting vanish completely and the flagged/dead threshold increased dramatically. It is too easy to drown out otherwise thoughtful, quality contributions to discussion. Instead we see two to three word witty quips float by unscathed. It is the antithesis of the type of discussion described in the guidelines and runs counter to the curation of substantive, meaningful discourse.

Re: Ask HN: What would it take for you to stop using Hacker News?

#10
I would like to see more of the "invisible web" showing up on the front page. As primarily tech people we should be more familiar with the older and wiser corners of the web and not just a slew of attention grabbing headlines.

I have found some of the most fascinating and thought provoking gems on HN over the years which would have otherwise been lost to antiquity. That is something unique that HN brings to the table as opposed to the multitudes of curated headline feeds out there.

As other commenters state here, the paywalled MSM stuff should take a backseat.

Old timers should be encouraged to submit some of their time-tested and well-worn articles to foster a more stable grounding in the tech industry for the newcomers.

Post reply on HN