Live data from Hacker News

JPL's Plan for the Next Mars Helicopter

spectrum.ieee.org

1–10 of 114 posts

Re: JPL's Plan for the Next Mars Helicopter

#5
post #3

Wonder if it is practical to design Helicopter with nuclear battery similar to the rover....

Plutonium is really heavy, if you were to do that it strikes me that you'd be better off having some kind of wireless charging device which the helicopter lands on (But at that point why not solar power).

You'd probably already need some batteries anyway as I'm guessing that the transient spikes in power usage would probably exceed any RTG you could fit in a helicopter anyway.

Re: JPL's Plan for the Next Mars Helicopter

#6
post #3

Wonder if it is practical to design Helicopter with nuclear battery similar to the rover....

A radioisotope thermoelectric or betavoltaic generator would probably be too heavy for a helicopter, so you'd probably need something a lot more intense than simple radioactive decay.

Re: JPL's Plan for the Next Mars Helicopter

#8
post #3

Wonder if it is practical to design Helicopter with nuclear battery similar to the rover....

Much too much mass. The atmosphere on Mars is 6.518 millibars. Look to the structure and mass of terrestrial birds for a guide.

terrestrial birds which would all have far too low of a lift to weight ratio on mars to ever have any hope of flying. The current mars helicopter is pretty incredible

Re: JPL's Plan for the Next Mars Helicopter

#10
post #7
post #3

Wonder if it is practical to design Helicopter with nuclear battery similar to the rover....

Do you see any nuclear-powered aircraft flying around on Earth?

Earth also doesn't have any nuclear powered rovers driving on the surface and yet Mars does. Might have something to do with the fact that the risk to humans on Mars is slightly lower than on Earth,no?
Post reply on HN