Live data from Hacker News

Why Google's bookmark manager and Docs have purposefully bad UI

bookmarkos.com

1–10 of 137 posts

Re: Why Google's bookmark manager and Docs have purposefully bad UI

#3
This is assuming malice when you could assume incompetence (to whatever slight degree this stuff is).

Probably these things got put in a future release, or are in the backlog still. Well meaning product designers wanted them and can't have them or some other typical big-co reason a product gets little iteration.

Re: Why Google's bookmark manager and Docs have purposefully bad UI

#5
post #3

This is assuming malice when you could assume incompetence (to whatever slight degree this stuff is). Probably these things got put in a future release, or are in the backlog still. Well meaning product designers wanted them and can't have them or some other typical big-co reason a product gets little iteration.

Google Docs has existed for a 15 years and it’s UI has barely improved from what I remember.

Re: Why Google's bookmark manager and Docs have purposefully bad UI

#7
This is why I use a self-hosted bookmark manager like Shiori, although I concede that I haven't found an ideal bookmark manager yet. I wish Chrome would have never built both its own bookmark manager and password manager, as well as Firefox. I believe those types of tasks are best left up to the community, and that for the most part web browsers should not be trying to re-invent what is already there.

Re: Why Google's bookmark manager and Docs have purposefully bad UI

#9
post #5
post #3

This is assuming malice when you could assume incompetence (to whatever slight degree this stuff is). Probably these things got put in a future release, or are in the backlog still. Well meaning product designers wanted them and can't have them or some other typical big-co reason a product gets little iteration.

Google Docs has existed for a 15 years and it’s UI has barely improved from what I remember.

Have you seen Google's latest icons? They aren't exactly known for doing what is competent, sane, or useful.

It took them years and years to finally make the "Ignore Toll Roads" on Google maps not reset after you close the app, even after tons of bug reports with hundreds of responses.

Re: Why Google's bookmark manager and Docs have purposefully bad UI

#10
post #5
post #3

This is assuming malice when you could assume incompetence (to whatever slight degree this stuff is). Probably these things got put in a future release, or are in the backlog still. Well meaning product designers wanted them and can't have them or some other typical big-co reason a product gets little iteration.

Google Docs has existed for a 15 years and it’s UI has barely improved from what I remember.

Sheets has gone through massive improvements in features.

It's no Excel, especially for bigger sheets or complex functions, but it's been a good way to provide my website users with a web spreadsheet. I'm reminded this every 4 years when I need to install Excel.

Post reply on HN