Live data from Hacker News

Video Shows Two Bees Work Together to Unscrew a Soda Bottle

sciencealert.com

1–8 of 8 posts

Re: Video Shows Two Bees Work Together to Unscrew a Soda Bottle

#2
It's a little hard to see because of the shaky filming, but from the way the cap subtly tilts during the rotation it looks like it's not actually screwed on at all and is just resting on top. So this doesn't necessarily show them unscrewing the cap or even working together at all.

The best we can say from the video is that two bees were each trying to push under the cap and it rotated in the process because of the way the bees were oriented.

Re: Video Shows Two Bees Work Together to Unscrew a Soda Bottle

#4

It's a little hard to see because of the shaky filming, but from the way the cap subtly tilts during the rotation it looks like it's not actually screwed on at all and is just resting on top. So this doesn't necessarily show them unscrewing the cap or even working together at all. The best we can say from the video is that two bees were each trying to push under the cap and it rotated in the process because of the wa…

Agreed, the video is too short to show any significant rotation of the bottle cap.

Re: Video Shows Two Bees Work Together to Unscrew a Soda Bottle

#5

It's a little hard to see because of the shaky filming, but from the way the cap subtly tilts during the rotation it looks like it's not actually screwed on at all and is just resting on top. So this doesn't necessarily show them unscrewing the cap or even working together at all. The best we can say from the video is that two bees were each trying to push under the cap and it rotated in the process because of the wa…

Not that current neuroscience can explain that either :)

Re: Video Shows Two Bees Work Together to Unscrew a Soda Bottle

#6
post #5

It's a little hard to see because of the shaky filming, but from the way the cap subtly tilts during the rotation it looks like it's not actually screwed on at all and is just resting on top. So this doesn't necessarily show them unscrewing the cap or even working together at all. The best we can say from the video is that two bees were each trying to push under the cap and it rotated in the process because of the wa…

Not that current neuroscience can explain that either :)

You don't think that current science can explain a bee trying to push toward a food source that it can see and smell?

Re: Video Shows Two Bees Work Together to Unscrew a Soda Bottle

#7
post #5

It's a little hard to see because of the shaky filming, but from the way the cap subtly tilts during the rotation it looks like it's not actually screwed on at all and is just resting on top. So this doesn't necessarily show them unscrewing the cap or even working together at all. The best we can say from the video is that two bees were each trying to push under the cap and it rotated in the process because of the wa…

Not that current neuroscience can explain that either :)

Just like the tides. And magnets.

Re: Video Shows Two Bees Work Together to Unscrew a Soda Bottle

#8
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not that current neuroscience can explain that either :)

You don't think that current science can explain a bee trying to push toward a food source that it can see and smell?

It really can't. Smell isn't really undetood. Vision isn't understood. This is pretty clear when looking at modern robotics.