Live data from Hacker News

Foraging humans, mammals and birds who live in the same place behave similarly

bristol.ac.uk

1–10 of 24 posts

Re: Foraging humans, mammals and birds who live in the same place behave similarly

#4
It's always interesting to see how the press office paints these things as historic eureka moments. These results, while fascinating, are basically in line with what we call Behavioral Ecology and more specifically, Human Behavioral Ecology. The latter has emerged as a pretty strong framework in the past few years. This sort of support is nice to see (and there's been a decent bit of buzz about this particular paper!), but it's evolutionary rather than revolutionary.

Re: Foraging humans, mammals and birds who live in the same place behave similarly

#6

So, if we want to influence human behaviour in the modern world (first child at 20 or 30? Is aggression linked to desire / see to hunt?) can we take the lessons here and apply them to urban design?

Short answer: No. You should always be wary of trying to apply evolutionary models to achieve specific real-world goals. Given the past history here, I'll go out on a limb and say that it's always a mistake.

Even if it was the right choice, these sorts of things have a dizzying array of unintuitive results and even the academics involved are still working out a lot of the implications. In particular, we don't have a good understanding of how applicable these results (and the wider predictions of HBE) are to non-foraging human societies.

Re: Foraging humans, mammals and birds who live in the same place behave similarly

#7
post #2

Interesting, but is it surprising? I would expect most species to adapt to surroundings, and if something works well for one, then surely there is a large chance it may work for other species too?

I came away with a different take away.

Perhaps a sustainable ecosystem is more likely to thrive if those at the top follow the same model patterns of interaction.

.. and perhaps, the fact that there's an evolutionary biological precident suggests that we were in step with a sustainable model for longer than we've been out of step.

Re: Foraging humans, mammals and birds who live in the same place behave similarly

#8
Does anyone have access to the paper? The article really doesn't do enough for me. What are the 15 behaviors the biologist was tracking?

Here's the paper page: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6526/292 and sci-hub came up empty.

EDIT found a PDF download link here: https://osf.io/fw9ge/download

Post reply on HN