Live data from Hacker News

The Hanging Gardens of Babylon

analog-antiquarian.net

1–10 of 12 posts

Re: The Hanging Gardens of Babylon

#3
post #2

Apparently no contemporary sources place the Gardens at Babylon. The smart money is betting they were at Nineveh, instead.

Smart money would be looking into irrigation infrastructure and history of its development in Mesopotamia. They had to raise water for a "hanging" garden. That implies some sort of pump technology.

Re: The Hanging Gardens of Babylon

#4
post #2

Apparently no contemporary sources place the Gardens at Babylon. The smart money is betting they were at Nineveh, instead.

Here is an article discussing it more in depth. It does seem like Nineveh is the better candidate.

https://www.nationalgeographic.com/history/magazine/2020/07-...

Re: The Hanging Gardens of Babylon

#5
post #2

Apparently no contemporary sources place the Gardens at Babylon. The smart money is betting they were at Nineveh, instead.

Smart money would be looking into irrigation infrastructure and history of its development in Mesopotamia. They had to raise water for a "hanging" garden. That implies some sort of pump technology.

They used Archimedes screws, as noted in the article.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/0199662266/ is a very good book about the current state of research into the Hanging Gardens. As ncmncm notes, there is strong evidence that Babylon never had any such thing, but Nineveh did.

Re: The Hanging Gardens of Babylon

#7
post #2

Apparently no contemporary sources place the Gardens at Babylon. The smart money is betting they were at Nineveh, instead.

Not a lot of records survived the bronze age collapse & its extended aftermath. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

What you said is true.

However, the Assyrian Empire and NeoBabylonian Empire, are both Iron Age empires that emerged after the Bronze Age Collapse. So any sources about the Hanging Gardens of Babylon would not have been affected by the Bronze Age Collapse.

Re: The Hanging Gardens of Babylon

#10
post #2

Apparently no contemporary sources place the Gardens at Babylon. The smart money is betting they were at Nineveh, instead.

Smart money would be looking into irrigation infrastructure and history of its development in Mesopotamia. They had to raise water for a "hanging" garden. That implies some sort of pump technology.

Nineveh, not coincidentally, apparently had the first elevated aqueducts. With arches.
Post reply on HN