Live data from Hacker News

People expect technology to suck because it sucks

tonsky.me

1–10 of 437 posts

Re: People expect technology to suck because it sucks

#4
This might sound like a flippant question, but it's not.

Isn't the point of tech to tinker? When did problems become problems that you shouldn't try to solve, instead of a reason to learn about the tech?

I've really been down about technology lately, after working with 6-12th graders. They just don't get how anything works, if it doesn't immediately work for them. They don't want to take it apart and figure it out.

This blog piece just seems like more of that. Why bother with figuring out how things work when you can just throw them away?

Now get off my lawn, I guess.

Re: People expect technology to suck because it sucks

#5
post #4

This might sound like a flippant question, but it's not. Isn't the point of tech to tinker? When did problems become problems that you shouldn't try to solve, instead of a reason to learn about the tech? I've really been down about technology lately, after working with 6-12th graders. They just don't get how anything works, if it doesn't immediately work for them. They don't want to take it apart and figure it out. T…

.. sure, until you have to do something for realsies and the tech is the only way to do it. Then it's just fucking your life over.

Re: People expect technology to suck because it sucks

#6
I'll point out that many of these annoyances don't have equivalents on the command-line. And the annoyances I do have on the command line I can mostly work around with wrapping things in shell scripts, aliases, or functions.

It's nice to have a simple interface and high extensibility on top of it.

Re: People expect technology to suck because it sucks

#7
post #4

This might sound like a flippant question, but it's not. Isn't the point of tech to tinker? When did problems become problems that you shouldn't try to solve, instead of a reason to learn about the tech? I've really been down about technology lately, after working with 6-12th graders. They just don't get how anything works, if it doesn't immediately work for them. They don't want to take it apart and figure it out. T…

.. sure, until you have to do something for realsies and the tech is the only way to do it. Then it's just fucking your life over.

Explain further, please. I don't think I'm following you.

Re: People expect technology to suck because it sucks

#9
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

.. sure, until you have to do something for realsies and the tech is the only way to do it. Then it's just fucking your life over.

Explain further, please. I don't think I'm following you.

It's one thing to tinker with Linux to learn how the OS works and another thin to troubleshoot it just as you are about to give a presentation.

Re: People expect technology to suck because it sucks

#10
post #4

This might sound like a flippant question, but it's not. Isn't the point of tech to tinker? When did problems become problems that you shouldn't try to solve, instead of a reason to learn about the tech? I've really been down about technology lately, after working with 6-12th graders. They just don't get how anything works, if it doesn't immediately work for them. They don't want to take it apart and figure it out. T…

People want to drive cars, not all of them want to be mechanics.

People want their phones and software to just work. Or at the very least not get bricked every friggin update.

Post reply on HN