Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 48 posts

Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

#1
This is a judgement-free zone if you're looking for something to downvote go look somewhere else.

Surely we can escape the collective groupthink a little to share some of our most unpopular opinions and theories?

I've got a few of my own so I'll kick it off in the comments --

Re: Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

#2
How we dress at work makes way more of a difference than we understand.

The main reason startup culture sucks people up and spits out their bones is because we've taken the worst parts of corporacy and left all the best ones to rot.

If a manager doesn't understand the importance of dressing up at least a few days a week he doesn't deserve the responsibility and most of the problems in this corporate world are down to young men who haven't discovered themselves but are willing to sacrifice all their energies in proving they're the best at something they know very little about.

Re: Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

#3
post #2

How we dress at work makes way more of a difference than we understand. The main reason startup culture sucks people up and spits out their bones is because we've taken the worst parts of corporacy and left all the best ones to rot. If a manager doesn't understand the importance of dressing up at least a few days a week he doesn't deserve the responsibility and most of the problems in this corporate world are down to…

I fully disagree with dressing up at work as being important. I fully agree that many of our problems at work stem from folks trying to prove that they are competent/best at something they are largely ignorant at. Some of these people dress up professionally to help hide their lack of effectiveness.

Dressing up for work is value signalling. "oh, a blazer? They are important." When it comes to client interactions, depending on the culture of the industry, being more professionally dressed is important. First impressions and all that. Self-confidence can be boosted by your appearance and that can help when interacting with folks. I've seen it work for folks that talk on the phone to customers. The other thing that helps boost confidence? Actually knowing what you are talking about :) I may not trust an investment representative as much if they are in their sweat pants compared to a suit. But for knowledge workers, I think there is a boon to being comfortable.

Re: Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

#4
Seemingly unpopular opinion (with a lens of Go programming): Don't mock dependencies. It is brittle. Stub/fake with dependency injection. It is unimportant that a function was called N times with arguments foo and bar. What is important is that unit tests validate that units output what they should output (success and error cases) and that integration tests ensure things work together.

Re: Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

#6
┬─┬ノ( º _ ºノ)

The mainstream media is often more factual and less biased than alternative media.

The modern web is superior by almost any objective measure, including quality of content, to the web of the 90s. Yes, this even includes content on services and social media.

RMS got what he deserved.

Significant whitespace is just a slightly messier form of brackets using non-printing characters. The elegance is an illusion.

Languages which compile to javascript are just linters with delusions of grandeur.

Firefox > Chrome

Lisp has syntax.

(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻

Re: Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

#7
- Public school and forcing kids to go to school is incredibly harmful to children, parents, families, and society. Forcing children to go to school is completely unnecessary.

- Mutual credit is a superior monetary system to our current one in every way: An elastic money supply, no bank runs, access to credit for everyone, no inflation, decentralized with no central bank, no moral hazard from seigniorage.

- Advertising is a wonderful sustainable business model that benefits both the consumer and business. There is no privacy issue that causes anyone harm from advertising.

- Business with large or complete market share is not bad at all or harmful to consumers, and the only true monopoly comes from government legally protecting a business from competition.

Re: Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

#9
post #2

How we dress at work makes way more of a difference than we understand. The main reason startup culture sucks people up and spits out their bones is because we've taken the worst parts of corporacy and left all the best ones to rot. If a manager doesn't understand the importance of dressing up at least a few days a week he doesn't deserve the responsibility and most of the problems in this corporate world are down to…

I fully disagree with dressing up at work as being important. I fully agree that many of our problems at work stem from folks trying to prove that they are competent/best at something they are largely ignorant at. Some of these people dress up professionally to help hide their lack of effectiveness. Dressing up for work is value signalling. "oh, a blazer? They are important." When it comes to client interactions, dep…

Bro I appreciate your reply and I want to remind you this is a wildly unpopular opinions thread so I'd encourage you to try to look at things from a different angle than playing the "I disagree" card which carries no merit here whatsoever.

As a hint I'd like to convey that the blazer is actually a dress down apparel compared to the outfits it replaced and the suit is designed as the ultimate comfort and convenience garment so if you can't feel comfortable in a suit and assume therefore it's impossible to for anyone to be comfortable in one, maybe you just haven't found the right tailor you know?

Which goes to my point that people don't understand what dressing up even means let alone how to do it.

Re: Ask HN: Wildly Unpopular Opinions

#10

- Public school and forcing kids to go to school is incredibly harmful to children, parents, families, and society. Forcing children to go to school is completely unnecessary. - Mutual credit is a superior monetary system to our current one in every way: An elastic money supply, no bank runs, access to credit for everyone, no inflation, decentralized with no central bank, no moral hazard from seigniorage. - Advertisi…

Wow! 100% agree on public schooling, I've witnessed it firsthand here during the pandemic. The kids were way better off without it.

I'm feeling your other points too. It's funny how wrong we can be about such fundamental issues.

Post reply on HN