Live data from Hacker News

Social Networking Is Not a Business*

technologyreview.com

1–10 of 11 posts

Re: Social Networking Is Not a Business*

#4

Almost no (current) social networks provide a service - they provide a distraction. And we're supposed to be surprised that they're having a hard time making money?

I would argue distraction is a service, but not an easy one to monetize, at least in this form.

Re: Social Networking Is Not a Business*

#6
post #4

Almost no (current) social networks provide a service - they provide a distraction. And we're supposed to be surprised that they're having a hard time making money?

I would argue distraction is a service, but not an easy one to monetize, at least in this form.

It's easy to make money if you're willing to set a price. The trouble for web-based distractions is that they're afraid the price will be too high and kill their traffic.

Weewar.com is a solid game, but it's still just a distraction. The way they're making money is by providing a "pro" version where you get access to more distractions: http://weewar.com/upgrade

Re: Social Networking Is Not a Business*

#7
post #4

Almost no (current) social networks provide a service - they provide a distraction. And we're supposed to be surprised that they're having a hard time making money?

I would argue distraction is a service, but not an easy one to monetize, at least in this form.

I'd say "entertainment" is a service. Although entertainment can be a distraction, it's a) not necessarily a distraction; b) a component of being entertainment. Purely (or at least mainly) being a distraction isn't a service. And it's hard to think of most "social networks" as much of anything more than a distraction.

Really, of the major social networks, I can't think of one that does anything that's not done better somewhere else. And, at least so far, no social networking site has combined those services in a synergistic way.

Re: Social Networking Is Not a Business*

#9

Almost no (current) social networks provide a service - they provide a distraction. And we're supposed to be surprised that they're having a hard time making money?

http://www.realitywanted.com

Read about them in my local paper. They actually charge for premium features.

Re: Social Networking Is Not a Business*

#10
That's because the social networks haven't opened up the floodgates yet, they're still in data collection mode. The real revenues come when they sell your data -- when Facebook tells Miller that you are a central person in your social network who just sent a message about Bud Light to a frat buddy -- that's when Miller sends you a special offer for your next party and when the real revenues for Facebook come.
Post reply on HN