An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
betterexplained.com
An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
1–10 of 105 posts
Re: An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
#2Of course AB != BA
Composition makes sense
Inverse makes sense
This is the book that helped me get it http://linear.axler.net/
Re: An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
#3Why is that? Has anyone studied it, or is there even a solid anecdotal explanation? The best one I can imagine is many of these professors simply don't care much for teaching and are more focused on their research, which is still infuriating but at least an explanation.
I ended up with an undergrad in applied math, though I'm a software engineer now. I like math, but I feel like I never got to be all that great at it. I suspect I would've enjoyed it more and achieved more with explanations like these.
Re: An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
#4Re: An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
#5I love explainers like this, but it frankly makes me a little angry that the vast majority of the math teachers I had in highschool and college taught in the awful way described in the setup to the piece. Why is that? Has anyone studied it, or is there even a solid anecdotal explanation? The best one I can imagine is many of these professors simply don't care much for teaching and are more focused on their research,…
For example the author uses the word function liberally in the explanation. However, when studying functions in school in math it was super complicated for me. It was only after I started programming, learning the programming language meaning of function, and then when I was reintroduced to mathematical functions through functional programming that I truly grasped mathematical functions and all the stuff I was taught in school.
I’m not arguing that school level math does not need to be improved. I just think we should be cautious that because an explanation that seems intuitive to us now after having gained a complete introduction to all math concepts as well as programming (esp on HN) may not necessarily be as intuitive when students who are only exposed to a very small subset of mathematical concepts encounter them.
Re: An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
#6I just wanted to give some context to how I found this page, and why I thought it would be good to post.
I may be putting myself on the spot here: I never took a linear algebra course in undergrad. It was a heavily encouraged option, of course, but I felt I understood the basic rules enough to not really need formal study. I opted to study other areas, partially motivated by a fear I wouldn't do well and would hurt my GPA (my god was I vain, I feel I could do so much more studying full-time with my current world-view).
As time has gone on, and ML and quantum computing have simply blown up since I graduated in 2014, I quickly realized the magnitude of my mistake. I have frantically self-studied for years to try to make up the gaps in my mathematical understanding, and linear algebra has come up time and time again. I can do the processes, but they never clicked, I had no intuition.
I want to help others in my position cut to the chase, and study the highest yield, most intuition giving resources.
I actually developed the mental model shared in this guide on my own, and was positively delighted to find to this while thinking over a comment I was drafting on here. This page lays things out so clearly. The component steps are intuitive and I can commit them to memory/recall what they mean without needing to dig up my notes to self!
===
I find this page gives an excellent foundation, and goes great with these resources:
* A web site which clearly shows how to do matrix multiplication in a way that's easy to recall, it makes the procedure like riding a bike:
http://matrixmultiplication.xyz/
Huge thanks to Jeremy Howard of fast.ai for mentioning this in one of his lectures, this tool is how I finally got matrix multiplication to click
* A paper named "An Introduction to Quantum Computing" (bear with me, it's superbly well written and very approachable):
https://arxiv.org/abs/0708.0261
Page 3 of that paper lays out matrix multiplication (e.g.: applying a "transformation matrix" in the spatial parlance of 3blue1brown's videos) as a traversal of a directed graph. A very useful understanding, and shows how generalizable the tools of linear algebra really are in my opinion.
* The essence of linear algebra, by 3blue1brown (fantastic for a geometric/"transformation of space" view of linear alg):
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZHQObOWTQDPD3MizzM2x...
Re: An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
#7Discussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4633662
Re: An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
#8I remember taking Advanced Algebra Honors in 10th grade. It was basically Algebra II with a few (seemingly teacher-selected based on the experience of students who had a different teacher) advanced topics thrown in. One of them was matrices, and I was completely stumped by them. I now encounter them all the time, and wish I'd been able to wrap my head around them when I was younger.
Re: An Intuitive Guide to Linear Algebra (2012)
#9Does this guy have a patreon?