Live data from Hacker News

Signs of cancer can appear long before diagnosis, study shows

theguardian.com

1–10 of 75 posts

Re: Signs of cancer can appear long before diagnosis, study shows

#2
... can appear in the genome long before ...

> “What’s extraordinary is how some of the genetic changes appear to have occurred many years before diagnosis, long before any other signs that a cancer may develop, and perhaps even in apparently normal tissue,” said Clemency Jolly, a co-author of the research based at the Francis Crick Institute in London.

Re: Signs of cancer can appear long before diagnosis, study shows

#6

Signs of cancer appear every time you consume animal protein.

Any sources for this? I'd like to learn more.

In a word? No.

There have been a couple studies done that suggest vegetarian diets are modestly cancer protective (~10% lower incidence). There have also been some that link increased meat consumption with increased risk of cancer. It's absolutely not clear that eating meat causes cancer. Dietary habits change your cancer mortality risk and being a vegetarian probably correlates with something like a 1-4% decreased risk.

I would be wildly surprised if there weren't animal protein inclusive diets that are good in other ways that surpass the cancer risk reduction of "being vegetarian".

Re: Signs of cancer can appear long before diagnosis, study shows

#7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any sources for this? I'd like to learn more.

In a word? No. There have been a couple studies done that suggest vegetarian diets are modestly cancer protective (~10% lower incidence). There have also been some that link increased meat consumption with increased risk of cancer. It's absolutely not clear that eating meat causes cancer. Dietary habits change your cancer mortality risk and being a vegetarian probably correlates with something like a 1-4% decreased r…

Yep, for example salmon and other fatty fish is widely recognized to be highly healthy food from cardiovascular point of view, and definitely doesn't increase cancer risk.

I don't think even red meat is necessarily so bad - rather it's the fact people in wealthy countries eat way too much of it compared to what humans have done most of our species history.

Re: Signs of cancer can appear long before diagnosis, study shows

#8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any sources for this? I'd like to learn more.

In a word? No. There have been a couple studies done that suggest vegetarian diets are modestly cancer protective (~10% lower incidence). There have also been some that link increased meat consumption with increased risk of cancer. It's absolutely not clear that eating meat causes cancer. Dietary habits change your cancer mortality risk and being a vegetarian probably correlates with something like a 1-4% decreased r…

Vegetarians are more likely than the general population to be non-smokers - an obvious cancer risk that many studies do not control for.

Re: Signs of cancer can appear long before diagnosis, study shows

#9
> The findings, based on samples from more than 2,500 tumours ...

Findings based on tumors sound like 20/20 hindsight!

If your crystal ball tells you where in a body tumor will develop five years from now, then if you look at the cells there, you might see some subtle signs that you know are not false positives.

Somehow, I don't think I'm holding my breath for new screening tests.

Re: Signs of cancer can appear long before diagnosis, study shows

#10
Lately I've been doing 7 day fasts two times a year mostly to reduce visceral fat and reduce my chance of type 2 diabetes. However a lot of science is pointing to it being a good way to reduce cancer risk. Nothing definitive, but it's nice to think I may be helping my body fight possible cancer too. Maybe I will catch some of these things early during these phases where the genes are present but the cancer hasn't begun to be diagnosable or slow it down.

I've also heard some doctors suggest that fasting during cancer treatment improves the effectiveness of chemotherapy.

Post reply on HN