Live data from Hacker News

Zuckerberg’s Anti-China Rhetoric Roils Facebook's Chinese Employees

theinformation.com

1–10 of 96 posts

Re: Zuckerberg’s Anti-China Rhetoric Roils Facebook's Chinese Employees

#3
> complaints of anti-China bias

Zuckerberg is quite clearly being critical of the Chinese Communist Party, who by nature of being authoritarian, have no mandate from the people of the PRC. There is no bias against China as a country, or Chinese people. Zuck is merely judging an authoritarian government for it's own actions. Shame on those who would wish to conflate the two.

Re: Zuckerberg’s Anti-China Rhetoric Roils Facebook's Chinese Employees

#5
Puzzle me this - as an employee in the US, for a company paying well above market for your labor, with generous perks and the freedom to speak out against the employer (which is likely absent in China), the response of the Chinese workforce seems rather paradoxical - criticising an accommodating work environment, which, mind you, is only possible because of freedom of speech

Or, the press is out to make a mountain of a mole - most Chinese employees at Facebook are happy despite Zuks' tone against the govt.

Re: Zuckerberg’s Anti-China Rhetoric Roils Facebook's Chinese Employees

#6
post #3

> complaints of anti-China bias Zuckerberg is quite clearly being critical of the Chinese Communist Party, who by nature of being authoritarian, have no mandate from the people of the PRC. There is no bias against China as a country, or Chinese people. Zuck is merely judging an authoritarian government for it's own actions. Shame on those who would wish to conflate the two.

Bit of a mirror to the tightrope of people trying to discuss objections to the Israeli governments actions.

Re: Zuckerberg’s Anti-China Rhetoric Roils Facebook's Chinese Employees

#8

Puzzle me this - as an employee in the US, for a company paying well above market for your labor, with generous perks and the freedom to speak out against the employer (which is likely absent in China), the response of the Chinese workforce seems rather paradoxical - criticising an accommodating work environment, which, mind you, is only possible because of freedom of speech Or, the press is out to make a mountain of…

Nationalism is nationalism regardless of said nation.

Re: Zuckerberg’s Anti-China Rhetoric Roils Facebook's Chinese Employees

#9
post #7

Title should read: "Zuckerberg’s Anti-China Rhetoric Roils (Chinese) Facebook Employees" At any rate, I applaud Zuckerberg for actually having a spine when it comes to China, unlike Tim Cook.

Agreed. Tim Cook seems laser focused on shipping as much of our semiconductor industry to China as possible.

Re: Zuckerberg’s Anti-China Rhetoric Roils Facebook's Chinese Employees

#10
post #3

> complaints of anti-China bias Zuckerberg is quite clearly being critical of the Chinese Communist Party, who by nature of being authoritarian, have no mandate from the people of the PRC. There is no bias against China as a country, or Chinese people. Zuck is merely judging an authoritarian government for it's own actions. Shame on those who would wish to conflate the two.

In order to understand why this conflation is occurring, you need to understand chinese culture. Chinese culture is very different in some fundamental ways that's hard for western countries to understand. First of all, the people in China are trained from a very early age to think of themselves as indistinguishable from their country and their government. There literally is no concept of self in China. People are tauhgt to think of themselves as completely the same as their government. this is a fundamental viewpoint of how the chinese see themselves. This of course allows the PRC to do whatever it wants without any complaints from the people because any thoughts against the PRC is tantamount to being anti-chinese. Thus when chinese people see anything that goes against the PRC they take it as a personal insult to themselves. The PRC has influenced their people to regard any idea that goes against the PRC as racism towards chinese.
Post reply on HN