Live data from Hacker News

I chose Facebook over Uber on 1/18/2019, which grossed me $92k.

huntermonk.com

1–10 of 33 posts

Re: I chose Facebook over Uber on 1/18/2019, which grossed me $92k.

#5

the story of how one person accepts the offer that pays more in equity, salary and bonus, and make more money than the other. such an economic genius

When I chose Facebook, I believed that Uber was a better offer. A $100B+ valuation for them seemed plausible to me. I thought I was going to be making $35-55k less.

So, I actually was not a genius here. It was total luck.

People rarely examine their non-decisions ("what would my life be like if I went left at that fork in the road?"), and I thought this was a particularly clear-cut example of that.

Re: I chose Facebook over Uber on 1/18/2019, which grossed me $92k.

#6

the story of how one person accepts the offer that pays more in equity, salary and bonus, and make more money than the other. such an economic genius

right. what was the moral lesson of this story? that I should flip coins for profit or that the FAANGs are prone to hiring millennials who don't share the same shame as my generation in discussing their financials so openly?

Re: I chose Facebook over Uber on 1/18/2019, which grossed me $92k.

#7

the story of how one person accepts the offer that pays more in equity, salary and bonus, and make more money than the other. such an economic genius

right. what was the moral lesson of this story? that I should flip coins for profit or that the FAANGs are prone to hiring millennials who don't share the same shame as my generation in discussing their financials so openly?

No moral lesson here - I suppose my point is that you rarely get to have such a clear-cut comparison of what would've happened if you took the other path at the fork in the road.

I can see where it comes off as gloating, though. Do you think I should modify this to focus more on the fork aspect? (genuine question)

Re: I chose Facebook over Uber on 1/18/2019, which grossed me $92k.

#8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

right. what was the moral lesson of this story? that I should flip coins for profit or that the FAANGs are prone to hiring millennials who don't share the same shame as my generation in discussing their financials so openly?

No moral lesson here - I suppose my point is that you rarely get to have such a clear-cut comparison of what would've happened if you took the other path at the fork in the road. I can see where it comes off as gloating, though. Do you think I should modify this to focus more on the fork aspect? (genuine question)

it's hard to make a story about you making money compelling unless you have something to share that can help others get there too. there's not too much of that here (and i'm not sure there could be in this case)

Re: I chose Facebook over Uber on 1/18/2019, which grossed me $92k.

#9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No moral lesson here - I suppose my point is that you rarely get to have such a clear-cut comparison of what would've happened if you took the other path at the fork in the road. I can see where it comes off as gloating, though. Do you think I should modify this to focus more on the fork aspect? (genuine question)

it's hard to make a story about you making money compelling unless you have something to share that can help others get there too. there's not too much of that here (and i'm not sure there could be in this case)

That's a good point - I added a small conclusion which possibly helps.
Post reply on HN