Live data from Hacker News

Canadian cities take wooden skyscrapers to new heights

theguardian.com

1–10 of 24 posts

Re: Canadian cities take wooden skyscrapers to new heights

#2
Note that the Brock Commons mentioned in the article is a bit of a hybrid as the structural core is a pair of concrete stairwells.

Norway's Mjøstårnet however (which took the palm from Brock) is structurally fully wooden, concrete is only used as stabiliser for the upper stories (inbetween the upper 7 stories to limit swaying), it's not load-bearing.

Re: Canadian cities take wooden skyscrapers to new heights

#6
For someone who are knowledgeable about using wood for large buildings: how does it stack against the weather?

I live a few miles from the largest in Norway[1], and if I recall, it's all exposed. Perhaps some protection is added as of late. However, I also know that using oil-based paint on the cladding increases the risk for rot if water gets trapped inside. How do you need protect exposed wood for centuries to come..

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mjøstårnet

Re: Canadian cities take wooden skyscrapers to new heights

#7
They glossed over the “wood is viewed as fire prone” thing and I can’t find the article posted to HN a few months back which discusses it further. The gist was wood protects itself with an insulating layer of charcoal as it starts to burn, and it maintains its strength when heated much better than steel, which starts to bend and cause a cascade failure.

Re: Canadian cities take wooden skyscrapers to new heights

#8

For someone who are knowledgeable about using wood for large buildings: how does it stack against the weather? I live a few miles from the largest in Norway[1], and if I recall, it's all exposed. Perhaps some protection is added as of late. However, I also know that using oil-based paint on the cladding increases the risk for rot if water gets trapped inside. How do you need protect exposed wood for centuries to come…

As I recall, you got some old wood buildings in Norway already, how are they maintained?

Re: Canadian cities take wooden skyscrapers to new heights

#9

For someone who are knowledgeable about using wood for large buildings: how does it stack against the weather? I live a few miles from the largest in Norway[1], and if I recall, it's all exposed. Perhaps some protection is added as of late. However, I also know that using oil-based paint on the cladding increases the risk for rot if water gets trapped inside. How do you need protect exposed wood for centuries to come…

Humans have thousands of years experience with wood and weather. Traditional wooden building withstands weather and rot quite well when you take care of the building.

Modern wood materials can be very technical and require less care. I would imagine that the exterior walls are heavily treated. Pressure-treated lumber can be very rot resistant. How resistant depends on how much you add chemicals. Wood can treated so that it's not rotting in direct contact with water and soil if needed. Modern preservatives are have soluble copper in them. Antimicrobial properties of copper are well known. If you pressure treat wood with these preservatives microbes don't rot them.

Post reply on HN