Live data from Hacker News

The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

technologyreview.com

1–10 of 91 posts

Re: The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

#2
It's things like this that make me think all engineers need more training on the social consequences of the tools they build.

This is an extreme case and I hope most engineers would look at this and understand how awful & damaging it could be; but given our influence on the world nowadays (as a class, if not always as individuals) we really need to be much more aware of what we're doing and how it affects people.

Re: The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

#3
post #2

It's things like this that make me think all engineers need more training on the social consequences of the tools they build. This is an extreme case and I hope most engineers would look at this and understand how awful & damaging it could be; but given our influence on the world nowadays (as a class, if not always as individuals) we really need to be much more aware of what we're doing and how it affects people.

[flagged]

Re: The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

#4
I'm not sure I understand the GDPR argument here. Is collecting the facial information from actors and actresses in porn movies illegal? Or was it the access of their social media accounts? Why is the tallying of what is publicly consumable a violation of GDPR?

Re: The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

#5
post #2

It's things like this that make me think all engineers need more training on the social consequences of the tools they build. This is an extreme case and I hope most engineers would look at this and understand how awful & damaging it could be; but given our influence on the world nowadays (as a class, if not always as individuals) we really need to be much more aware of what we're doing and how it affects people.

The problem is that engineers are not always the ones in charge of the entire end result. If you want to do something unethical you can just split it up into harmless individual tasks and give it to a dozen engineers and then put it all together. It’s obfuscation.

Some of the greatest atrocities we will see in tech (and we will see them) in the coming century will be the result of combining things created with good intentions.

Not much we can do I’m afraid except endure.

Re: The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

#6

I'm not sure I understand the GDPR argument here. Is collecting the facial information from actors and actresses in porn movies illegal? Or was it the access of their social media accounts? Why is the tallying of what is publicly consumable a violation of GDPR?

[flagged]

Re: The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

#7

I'm not sure I understand the GDPR argument here. Is collecting the facial information from actors and actresses in porn movies illegal? Or was it the access of their social media accounts? Why is the tallying of what is publicly consumable a violation of GDPR?

[flagged]

Is it tho

Re: The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

#8

I'm not sure I understand the GDPR argument here. Is collecting the facial information from actors and actresses in porn movies illegal? Or was it the access of their social media accounts? Why is the tallying of what is publicly consumable a violation of GDPR?

GDPR deals with processing of personal data, not just collection or canonical records of it. If personal data passes through a system, it’s probably covered by GDPR.

Re: The guy who made a tool to track women in porn videos is sorry

#9
post #5
post #2

It's things like this that make me think all engineers need more training on the social consequences of the tools they build. This is an extreme case and I hope most engineers would look at this and understand how awful & damaging it could be; but given our influence on the world nowadays (as a class, if not always as individuals) we really need to be much more aware of what we're doing and how it affects people.

The problem is that engineers are not always the ones in charge of the entire end result. If you want to do something unethical you can just split it up into harmless individual tasks and give it to a dozen engineers and then put it all together. It’s obfuscation. Some of the greatest atrocities we will see in tech (and we will see them) in the coming century will be the result of combining things created with good i…

An engineer can quit if the project is unethical. Just 'enduring' is harmful to yourself, and others. Don't be a coward, at least stand up for your values.
Post reply on HN