Live data from Hacker News

Starlink satellite-train visible with the naked eye

twitter.com

1–10 of 47 posts

Re: Starlink satellite-train visible with the naked eye

#3

Is this only until they are in position or are going to see this everytime they fly over?

You’ll be able to see them as individual dots any time they’re illuminated by the sun when they fly over at night (like any other satellite), but they won’t be bunched together like this.

Re: Starlink satellite-train visible with the naked eye

#5
Counted 52 spots, plus an additional 2 which only appeared briefly and dimly, a little off the track of the others. 4 or 5 dots seem to be pairs. So that acounts for pretty much all satellites. I'd like to experience this for myself. With 12000 of them the sky will be quite littered with them though. Astronomy will never be the same again.

Re: Starlink satellite-train visible with the naked eye

#6
Okay that's interesting but I have to say it's also quite ugly. Is this a new trend to cluster satellites like this? If so what advantage does it bring and is it worth that ugly streak appearing in the night?

I get this comment is very subjective but surely I'm not the only one thinking it's a bit of an eyesore

Re: Starlink satellite-train visible with the naked eye

#7

Okay that's interesting but I have to say it's also quite ugly. Is this a new trend to cluster satellites like this? If so what advantage does it bring and is it worth that ugly streak appearing in the night? I get this comment is very subjective but surely I'm not the only one thinking it's a bit of an eyesore

They are currently spreading out and once they have spread out enough they will move on their own power to their final orbits.

Re: Starlink satellite-train visible with the naked eye

#8
post #3

Is this only until they are in position or are going to see this everytime they fly over?

You’ll be able to see them as individual dots any time they’re illuminated by the sun when they fly over at night (like any other satellite), but they won’t be bunched together like this.

And astronomers where 'enjoying' the last Iridium Flares (their new satellites don't produce the flare). :)

Re: Starlink satellite-train visible with the naked eye

#9
post #7

Okay that's interesting but I have to say it's also quite ugly. Is this a new trend to cluster satellites like this? If so what advantage does it bring and is it worth that ugly streak appearing in the night? I get this comment is very subjective but surely I'm not the only one thinking it's a bit of an eyesore

They are currently spreading out and once they have spread out enough they will move on their own power to their final orbits.

Hmmm well I hope it's not noticeable because starlink is planning 24 orbital planes with 60 satellites per. With that it's safe to say you could see up to 50 or so of them in a night due to the constellation pattern. That's a lot of flickering and moving light in the sky when coupled with AWS' initiative also. I'm hoping your right but at first glance it doesn't seem great.
Post reply on HN