Live data from Hacker News

Gravitee: Open-Source API Gateway

gravitee.io

1–10 of 47 posts

Re: Gravitee: Open-Source API Gateway

#3
Why none of these API gateways offer monetization out of the box? I'm curious. Is that a not well-demanded feature?

I have researched a lot of them and none have a straight way to do metered billing and if they somehow do, they are prohibitively expensive.

Does somebody know of an API gateway solution that offers this?

Re: Gravitee: Open-Source API Gateway

#5

Not speaking about the project itself, but since when did 100% Open Source become a thing?

Kong has Community Edition and an Enterprise Edition with non-free/proprietary features (same model as MySQL, Nginx, GitLab, & Redis). It's called the open-core model. Company is signaling that it intends to offer all features open source and without restriction.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-core_model

Re: Gravitee: Open-Source API Gateway

#7

Why none of these API gateways offer monetization out of the box? I'm curious. Is that a not well-demanded feature? I have researched a lot of them and none have a straight way to do metered billing and if they somehow do, they are prohibitively expensive. Does somebody know of an API gateway solution that offers this?

Billing is a hard issue since there is no common API to do that. All payment gateways are different. And what is most important, it lot of cases it requires some application logic, on how exactly you want to bill the user: for example partly static, partly dynamic.

What API gateway can do, is to provide you with a way to set a quota for a given user, track analytics, and have it all accessed in a programmatic way, so with a few API queries, you can know how much to bill the user. At least that's how most of the Gateways, like Tyk, do.

Re: Gravitee: Open-Source API Gateway

#8
Wso2 has a fully ASLv2 licensed API management solution which also includes a high performance gateway. It has monetization items included. Deployed to 1000s of accounts and running some environments with billions of transactions a day. Excited to take a look at this new entrant.

Re: Gravitee: Open-Source API Gateway

#10

Why none of these API gateways offer monetization out of the box? I'm curious. Is that a not well-demanded feature? I have researched a lot of them and none have a straight way to do metered billing and if they somehow do, they are prohibitively expensive. Does somebody know of an API gateway solution that offers this?

Apigee has some monetization features... https://docs.apigee.com/api-platform/monetization/basics-mon...
Post reply on HN