Live data from Hacker News

First-ever DNSSEC root key rollover

redhat.com

1–10 of 75 posts

Re: First-ever DNSSEC root key rollover

#4
post #2

I have a DNSSEC signed zone, do I need to do anything? Like generate a new key using this new root key?

No, because nobody really depends on DNSSEC, so nothing will break:

- https://ianix.com/pub/dnssec-outages.html

- https://twitter.com/tqbf/status/772103926258671618

Re: First-ever DNSSEC root key rollover

#7

To check DNSSEC: https://dnssec-name-and-shame.com To check DANE (such as freebsd.org port 443): https://www.huque.com/bin/danecheck

The dnssec-name-and-shame site makes an incredibly loud noise if the site you type in happens to not be compliant or whatever. Be sure to remove your headphones before clicking any links in the above comment.

Re: First-ever DNSSEC root key rollover

#8
What is the purpose of rolling over the key, if the new key is simply signed by the old one? Meaning it has exactly as much security as the old key did.

I can understand it if the new key was a different algorithm, or key-length or something. But what is the purpose in simply picking a new key?

Re: First-ever DNSSEC root key rollover

#9
post #8

What is the purpose of rolling over the key, if the new key is simply signed by the old one? Meaning it has exactly as much security as the old key did. I can understand it if the new key was a different algorithm, or key-length or something. But what is the purpose in simply picking a new key?

The old one will presumably eventually be expired. That means someone who compromised the old one can't hang onto their access indefinitely.

Re: First-ever DNSSEC root key rollover

#10
post #8

What is the purpose of rolling over the key, if the new key is simply signed by the old one? Meaning it has exactly as much security as the old key did. I can understand it if the new key was a different algorithm, or key-length or something. But what is the purpose in simply picking a new key?

If the old key has been unknowingly compromised, it is now replaced. The new key is not "simply" signed by the old one. You have to announce it for 30 days, making it harder to pull of a surreptitious switch.
Post reply on HN