Live data from Hacker News

The Scottish Register of Tartans

tartanregister.gov.uk

1–10 of 49 posts

Re: The Scottish Register of Tartans

#5
The good thing about this, is it puts tartans into a modern IPR context and sheds the Walter Scott fake history. It's no different to burberry trademarking it's red flash check. All the clan/sept/hunting/dress stuff is a giant fantasy of post Regency construction.

Harris Tweed on the other hand, is much more a "thing" and deserves its restricted mark for heritage reasons.

Cornish sailors knitting patterns next!

Re: The Scottish Register of Tartans

#7
post #5

The good thing about this, is it puts tartans into a modern IPR context and sheds the Walter Scott fake history. It's no different to burberry trademarking it's red flash check. All the clan/sept/hunting/dress stuff is a giant fantasy of post Regency construction. Harris Tweed on the other hand, is much more a "thing" and deserves its restricted mark for heritage reasons. Cornish sailors knitting patterns next!

Yeah - a lot of traditions were "revived" (i.e. invented) for the visit of King George IV to Scotland:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visit_of_King_George_IV_to_Sco...

Which is ironic given the almost ethnic cleaning levels of treatment given to Highlanders and their culture following the '45 and the later Clearances:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Culloden#Aftermath

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highland_Clearances

Re: The Scottish Register of Tartans

#8
post #5

The good thing about this, is it puts tartans into a modern IPR context and sheds the Walter Scott fake history. It's no different to burberry trademarking it's red flash check. All the clan/sept/hunting/dress stuff is a giant fantasy of post Regency construction. Harris Tweed on the other hand, is much more a "thing" and deserves its restricted mark for heritage reasons. Cornish sailors knitting patterns next!

Well, sugar and palm oil bottlers Nutella have just cranked up the computers to provide unique designs in every jar, e.g. https://www.nutella.com/en/au/uniquenutella (heavy, possibly slow)

Pampered, we are.

Re: The Scottish Register of Tartans

#9
post #6

Out of curiosity I checked out the "New Tartans" page. The most recent item is: https://www.tartanregister.gov.uk/tartanDetails?ref=12260 which, sadly, seems to have been registered on behalf of a white supremacist cult.

Dunno why you're getting downvoted, seems factual:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asatru_Folk_Assembly

Re: The Scottish Register of Tartans

#10
post #2

As a Scot, I was slightly surprised to see that this is actually an official Scottish Government service! Edit: I should have guessed by the domain.

As much as a lot of tartan-lore is revisionist, selling pretty cloth to credulous tourists and Americans-craving-heritage is big business.
Post reply on HN