Live data from Hacker News

Switzerland: First country to have national referendum about Sovereign Money

vollgeld-initiative.ch

1–10 of 33 posts

Re: Switzerland: First country to have national referendum about Sovereign Money

#3
post #2

For a website that proclaims the importance of getting the word out, I didn’t see any description of what this “sovereign money” proposal actually is. What is being proposed and why?

This may help with that: https://snb.ch/en/mmr/speeches/id/ref_20180116_tjn

Re: Switzerland: First country to have national referendum about Sovereign Money

#5
post #4

Here's a good explanation of what the sovereign money initiative is (and why it is probably a bad idea) from the chairman of the Swiss central bank: https://snb.ch/en/mmr/speeches/id/ref_20180116_tjn

And an FAQ/rebuttal: https://www.vollgeld-initiative.ch/fa/img/English/Clarificat...

Re: Switzerland: First country to have national referendum about Sovereign Money

#7
post #6

As somebody from Switzerland I think this is insane. I will vote against it. Honestly, most people who want this dont have a clue about monetary policy.

I'd liken it to Repblicanism vs Monarchism. The differences between the positions are pretty extreme; to the point where it is hard for normal people to educate themselves.

It looks like something I'd be in favour of. Not because I don't understand monetary policy but because I disagree with its goals, methods and outcomes.

Re: Switzerland: First country to have national referendum about Sovereign Money

#9
post #6

As somebody from Switzerland I think this is insane. I will vote against it. Honestly, most people who want this dont have a clue about monetary policy.

I'd liken it to Repblicanism vs Monarchism. The differences between the positions are pretty extreme; to the point where it is hard for normal people to educate themselves. It looks like something I'd be in favour of. Not because I don't understand monetary policy but because I disagree with its goals, methods and outcomes.

Repblicanism vs Monarchism seems a terrible comparison.

Re: Switzerland: First country to have national referendum about Sovereign Money

#10

Does "Banks won’t be able to create money for themselves any more" mean the same as ending fractional reserve banking, or am I misunderstanding things?

Perhaps, but it will be closer to banning bank lending (as it is fundamentally different from lending between individuals).

"Fractional reserve" is just a convenient scapegoat, as banks, once the rules and numbers are reviewed, do not lend from reserves. Any time they approve a loan, new money is put into circulation.

Post reply on HN