Live data from Hacker News

Lottery winner asking a judge to let her keep the cash and remain anonymous

msn.com

1–10 of 230 posts

Re: Lottery winner asking a judge to let her keep the cash and remain anonymous

#3
If you don't happen to read the article and think to mention the anonymous trust way of accepting the winnings. She can't do that either.

"The state allows people to form an anonymous trust, NewHampshire.com reported, but it’s a moot point for the woman — she signed her name on the back of the ticket shortly after winning, and altering the signature would nullify the ticket."

Oh and an excellent tidbit out of the story is that the attorney representing her actually blogged about the winner having been in NH and how the winner should not sign the back of the ticket. Apparently the ticket winner is now using that attorney to represent her in the courts. https://www.shaheengordon.com/New-Hampshire-Legal-Blog/2018/...

Re: Lottery winner asking a judge to let her keep the cash and remain anonymous

#4
I understand why people don't want everyone to know they're rich. I'm rich (not $560M, but some) and you can figure that out from various news stories, and it does affect relationships somewhat. More so outside Silicon Valley.

On the other hand, I understand why lotteries want to publicize winners in their marketing.

A fair deal might be, that the publicity value is defined to be X% (say 10%) of the prize, and you can take the full prize with publicity, or the prize - X% anonymously.

Re: Lottery winner asking a judge to let her keep the cash and remain anonymous

#5
My understanding is that the lotto wants free advertising at the cost of the winners being made very public.

It seems like this individual is doing a tremendous public service by taking this to court. I think most of us would balk at the risk of somehow losing the millions of dollars.

Re: Lottery winner asking a judge to let her keep the cash and remain anonymous

#6
I hope she wins. There's a pretty funny (or sad, I suppose) reddit comment about winning the lottery that seems pretty true:

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/24vzgl/you_just_...

Winning the lottery (publicly, at least) seems to be a real monkey's paw wish.

Re: Lottery winner asking a judge to let her keep the cash and remain anonymous

#8
I understand the desire to be anonymous, but things like this get out. While taking this route might benefit future winners, it will likely make her own situation worse via the "Streisand effect": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect

Re: Lottery winner asking a judge to let her keep the cash and remain anonymous

#9
post #4

I understand why people don't want everyone to know they're rich. I'm rich (not $560M, but some) and you can figure that out from various news stories, and it does affect relationships somewhat. More so outside Silicon Valley. On the other hand, I understand why lotteries want to publicize winners in their marketing. A fair deal might be, that the publicity value is defined to be X% (say 10%) of the prize, and you ca…

If I'm not mistaken, it's about more than just publicity; it's also about avoiding fraud. As someone put it before "come spend money on a chance to win a very large pot of money; don't worry, we have given some out before, but you just have to believe us".

Re: Lottery winner asking a judge to let her keep the cash and remain anonymous

#10
post #7

Too bad, so sad. Potential top 1% problems. I live from paycheque to paycheque. I have no sympathy for her. Why did she play in the first place?

Your lack of emotional depth is one of the many reasons you will likely remain out of the 1% wealth cohort. Best of luck.
Post reply on HN