Live data from Hacker News

Percentage of top grossing US films by decade that depict killing

blog.jgc.org

1–10 of 43 posts

Re: Percentage of top grossing US films by decade that depict killing

#4
As martijn points out in the comments, no conclusions can be drawn without data about the pool of all movies.

If it makes you feel better about the world, actual murders per capita is not significantly higher now than it was in the 1960's; I guess we've all figured out that life lessons don't come from blockbuster movies --- just fun explosions.

Re: Percentage of top grossing US films by decade that depict killing

#5
What is there to conclude, other than that people are more tolerant of killing being portrayed in films? After 1980, there's an inverse correlation between the frequency of murder or violent crime in the US and depiction of killing in film - the former goes down while the latter continues to increase. (http://www.disastercenter.com/crime/uscrime.htm)

Re: Percentage of top grossing US films by decade that depict killing

#8
Wow, I got it totally wrong. When I read this in my RSS, I read "firms" instead of films and I was wondering what all these businesses were doing portraying killing.

Then when I read the title correctly on HN, I remembered the graph going downward and thought it was weird that films were showing less killing. I clicked through and was surprised to see that the x-axis was descending chronological order.

So now that I finally get the graph, let me throw out a WAG: with the end of the military draft, the almost complete departure of workers from agriculture, and increasing safety in society, violence of any form and especially death is not a real part of most peoples' lives. It is therefore fair game for fantasy and storytelling because there is little negative emotional experience attached to it, but there is a high degree of novelty.

Post reply on HN