Live data from Hacker News

More Than 100 Universities and Colleges Included in Offshore Leaks Database

icij.org

1–10 of 71 posts

Re: More Than 100 Universities and Colleges Included in Offshore Leaks Database

#4
post #2

These "leaks" are annoying. They just give you a page with virtually no information, just a chart showing some connection. Release everything. Don't insult my intelligence by deciding for me what to release.

I partially agree with the parent. Showing these "connections" without any context and detail is just infuriating and leads to click-bait headlines with no actual purpose served.

I don't think they are trying to insult anyone's intelligence though. They are just being careful with the data so that their sources are safe.

While safety is important, this reminds me of the story of the boy who cried wolf. If they keep doing this multiple times and there is no substantial info., people will stop paying attention when there is some real info. and demagogues will use this as evidence of fake news.

Re: More Than 100 Universities and Colleges Included in Offshore Leaks Database

#5
post #2

These "leaks" are annoying. They just give you a page with virtually no information, just a chart showing some connection. Release everything. Don't insult my intelligence by deciding for me what to release.

They're not really deciding for you what to release, since you have nothing to release.

Is your concern that their interpretation of the source material is inaccurate, or that you're being intentionally misled or occluded?

The ICIJ has been around for two decades, and their credibility is robust. I don't think they're likely to be making claims like this without access to substantial evidence.

Re: More Than 100 Universities and Colleges Included in Offshore Leaks Database

#7
post #2

These "leaks" are annoying. They just give you a page with virtually no information, just a chart showing some connection. Release everything. Don't insult my intelligence by deciding for me what to release.

I think part of the reason they do this is because there's massive amounts of unorganized data. This would make it both difficult for individuals to analyze, and would also pose a privacy risk to people and organizations.

Re: More Than 100 Universities and Colleges Included in Offshore Leaks Database

#9
post #2

These "leaks" are annoying. They just give you a page with virtually no information, just a chart showing some connection. Release everything. Don't insult my intelligence by deciding for me what to release.

I partially agree with the parent. Showing these "connections" without any context and detail is just infuriating and leads to click-bait headlines with no actual purpose served. I don't think they are trying to insult anyone's intelligence though. They are just being careful with the data so that their sources are safe. While safety is important, this reminds me of the story of the boy who cried wolf. If they keep d…

The problem is that incorporation documents are frequently only a small part of the story. It does allow you to correlate ownership, but unless you can actually show some kind of money movement into and out of accounts, it is difficult to show evidence of a particular crime.

Re: More Than 100 Universities and Colleges Included in Offshore Leaks Database

#10
post #2

These "leaks" are annoying. They just give you a page with virtually no information, just a chart showing some connection. Release everything. Don't insult my intelligence by deciding for me what to release.

This is a lesson they learned from the cablegate: releasing a full stash of data is not going to get the public or even the journalists, interested.
Post reply on HN