Live data from Hacker News

John Carmack on Functional Programming (2013) [video]

youtube.com

1–10 of 90 posts

Re: John Carmack on Functional Programming (2013) [video]

#6
I wonder about the present state of the functional projects he talks about and is currently working on. A bit old, but good video talking about FP and static typing from a veteran perspective.

Would like to see a conversation between Sid Meier and Carmack, the modern Civ engines seem to have made some strides in stability methinks.

Re: John Carmack on Functional Programming (2013) [video]

#7
Interesting that he ran into friction exactly where you would expect him to.

He was talking about having the AI scripts running in different purely functional threads. Later (around 21 minutes in) he mentions what happens when two AIs decide to move to the same place at the same time, and has not figured out the solution.

Of course parallel programming is easy if you ignore the data dependencies, but eventually you run into unavoidable dependencies and your clean elegant system has to pick up some smell.

Re: John Carmack on Functional Programming (2013) [video]

#10
EDIT: Why all those downvotes? Are famous developers not supposed to criticized on HN?

While John has a lot of interesting things to say, the presentation is awful, almost an imposition to the audience.

There's not a single slide, or any repetition to clarify structure, or any notable gestures to make up for that. A simple overview, just a damn simple list of keywords, would already go a long way. That would add a lot of structure and would make the talk so much easier to follow, especially for non-native speakers.

Just because one is so much respected by the audience that they will tolerate everything, one should not act like the audience will tolerate everything.

Post reply on HN