Live data from Hacker News

The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

nationalgeographic.com

1–10 of 73 posts

Re: The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

#2
The Lunar X prize competition is really neat, and I'll follow raptly. But it's unlikely to do much for actually space exploration, just as the original X-Prize did little to advance access to space.

If SpaceX sends a manned Dragon around the moon, that's only going to be a thousand times more important than landing tiny rovers on the moon.

Re: The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

#3
The Lunar X prize competition is really neat, and I'll follow raptly. But it's unlikely to do much for actually space exploration, just as the original X-Prize did little to advance access to space.

If SpaceX sends a manned Dragon around the moon, that's only going to be a thousand times more important than landing tiny rovers on the moon.

Re: The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

#4
post #2

The Lunar X prize competition is really neat, and I'll follow raptly. But it's unlikely to do much for actually space exploration, just as the original X-Prize did little to advance access to space. If SpaceX sends a manned Dragon around the moon, that's only going to be a thousand times more important than landing tiny rovers on the moon.

Are you talking about spaceshipone?

Re: The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

#5
post #4
post #2

The Lunar X prize competition is really neat, and I'll follow raptly. But it's unlikely to do much for actually space exploration, just as the original X-Prize did little to advance access to space. If SpaceX sends a manned Dragon around the moon, that's only going to be a thousand times more important than landing tiny rovers on the moon.

Are you talking about spaceshipone?

I have often heard it refereed to as, Not A Space Ship One.

Even 160 kilometers has quite a bit of atmospheric drag, and Spaceshipone only just broke 100 kilometers.

Re: The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

#6
I have great hopes on Team Indus. Hoping they'll pull of this mission. They've signed a PSLV-XL launch contract with ISRO, and they seem to be on track with spacecraft and rover development[0]. Japan's X-prize entrant HAKUTO will also be ride-sharing on this mission[1].

It'll be an exciting 2018 for us, we have two moon rover missions from India - Chandrayaan 2 from ISRO[2], and Team Indus.

[0] https://medium.com/teamindus/teamindus-missionlog-august-67e...

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2016/12/20/14023336/google-lunar-x-...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chandrayaan-2

Re: The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

#8

These prizes really confuse me. Wouldn't it cost more than $20 million just to get something into LEO with existing technology? How can mounting a robotic lunar mission possibly be done for less than that?

yes - according to this: https://futurism.com/elon-musk-launching-a-satellite-with-sp... even spacex is maybe at least 68M for a satellite launch not even to the moon

Re: The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

#9

These prizes really confuse me. Wouldn't it cost more than $20 million just to get something into LEO with existing technology? How can mounting a robotic lunar mission possibly be done for less than that?

True, but it could potentially be coupled with government grants or other funding.

Re: The Next Moon Landing Is Near, Thanks to Pioneering Engineers

#10
post #2

The Lunar X prize competition is really neat, and I'll follow raptly. But it's unlikely to do much for actually space exploration, just as the original X-Prize did little to advance access to space. If SpaceX sends a manned Dragon around the moon, that's only going to be a thousand times more important than landing tiny rovers on the moon.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN