Live data from Hacker News

ICANN Approves Dot-XXX Domain for Porn

pcworld.com

1–10 of 38 posts

Re: ICANN Approves Dot-XXX Domain for Porn

#5
I wish the ICANN would knock it off. TLD's are not an effective way to group websites. They are making the namespace more complex for little or no benefit. Now that the horses are effectively out of the barn, they should just make the TLD registry replace the concept of a domain. Cannon already bought .cannon right?

Re: ICANN Approves Dot-XXX Domain for Porn

#7
Can someone explain to me how this helps the Internet ecosystem?

If I were a porn site, why would I want this address? Filters, parental controls, etc. are most likely going to block the entire .xxx domain - this would limit page views.

History has shown that .com is the most popular TLD - how is .xxx going to help? It seems like an attempt to drum up registrar dollars.

Re: ICANN Approves Dot-XXX Domain for Porn

#8
It wouldn't surprise me if the pornography industry didn't completely ignore this TLD. The nature of pornography means that it's possible to be very creative in naming your site.

If you look at Alexa's list of the top adult web sites you'd see the following names: livejasmin.com, pornhub.com, xvideos.com, youporn.com, xhamster.com, tube8.com, ...

It doesn't look to me like the .com namespace is running out of room for pornography.

Re: ICANN Approves Dot-XXX Domain for Porn

#9

Can someone explain to me how this helps the Internet ecosystem? If I were a porn site, why would I want this address? Filters, parental controls, etc. are most likely going to block the entire .xxx domain - this would limit page views. History has shown that .com is the most popular TLD - how is .xxx going to help? It seems like an attempt to drum up registrar dollars.

True, it would limit page views, but don't forget that (for better or worse) there are laws about viewing pornography across most of the country and much of the world as well. At least some of that traffic is coming illegally, and it may be only a matter of time before porn peddlers are held legally liable for that traffic.

I think it makes a lot of practical business sense to be able to unequivocably categorize your business.

Re: ICANN Approves Dot-XXX Domain for Porn

#10
post #8

It wouldn't surprise me if the pornography industry didn't completely ignore this TLD. The nature of pornography means that it's possible to be very creative in naming your site. If you look at Alexa's list of the top adult web sites you'd see the following names: livejasmin.com, pornhub.com, xvideos.com, youporn.com, xhamster.com, tube8.com, ... It doesn't look to me like the .com namespace is running out of room fo…

I would be surprised if every site doesn't immediately get their .xxx out of nervousness. How long until someone puts laws saying porn must be hosted on .xxx "for the children"? Sites using .com could be accused of trying to hide instead of clearly marking their dangerous content.

Idiotic, yes. So how probable?

Post reply on HN