Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Steve Jobs Doesn't Want Shit In His App Store, And Neither Do I

flyosity.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 23 posts

Re: Steve Jobs Doesn't Want Shit In His App Store, And Neither Do I

#3

Post by maxharris »

I agree with this completely! I think that 3.3.1 will make it easier to find good apps, and that alone will help keep Apple on top.

If Apple's policies are incorrect, people will switch increasingly to competing platforms. But that's not going to happen, because Apple makes great stuff! Other companies could do it, too - if they copied Apple's principles, and not just random features or random visual elements.

Re: Steve Jobs Doesn't Want Shit In His App Store, And Neither Do I

#4

Post by Seiwynn »

Are we really still having this discussion?

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1255858

I'd like to think that both sides are clear -

Steve Jobs - "We’ve been there before, and intermediate layers between the platform and the developer ultimately produces sub-standard apps and hinders the progress of the platform."

My point of view said well by the author of the article I linked - "Crappy developers will make crappy apps regardless of how many layers there are, and it doesn’t make sense to limit source-to-source conversion tools like Unity3D and others. They’re all building apps through the iPhone developer tools in the end so the situation isn’t even comparable to the Mac where applications can completely avoid using Apple’s frameworks by replacing them with others."

At this point I think we've reached the point of "agree to disagree", where neither side is going to change the other's mind.

Re: Steve Jobs Doesn't Want Shit In His App Store, And Neither Do I

#6

Post by telemachos »

We keep hearing this argument, but it simply cannot survive the facts of the App store.

After searching for 'fart', I stopped counting at 30 items. Are we supposed to believe that Objective C source code and Cocoa Touch style somehow turn this crapware into elegant masterpieces of 21st century design?

Re: Steve Jobs Doesn't Want Shit In His App Store, And Neither Do I

#7

Post by bad_user »

Truth is nobody knows shit about what Steve Jobs wants or about what the directions Apple has taken.

For all I care, this might be a maneuver to get rid of both the external competition (Android, WinMo, Symbian) and the internal one ... reducing developers on their platforms to mere contractors that are doing their bidding.

And you can't prove that I'm wrong because neither you nor I know shit about it.

So stop apologizing for them. If you believe their choices are for better quality, quality can speak by itself and nobody needs you rationalizations on the matter. It's as if you're defending your own choices and directions, which shows you have doubts.

On the other hand the bitching and moaning of mistreated customers (yeah, we are also customers) might do some good.

Re: Steve Jobs Doesn't Want Shit In His App Store, And Neither Do I

#8

Post by z5h »

This guy uses jQuery on some of his sites. The language used in jQuery's selectors is a superset of CSS. That's right, it's not CSS. jQuery is translating/interpreting that new language for you. jQuery is more than just JavaScript it's an interpreter/compiler for a new language. (FYI, not allowed by Apple's rules).

For some reason when this guy target multiple browsers using jQuery it's OK. But when other developers target multiple platforms he calls the end result "shit" and tells them to get the hell out of his AppStore.

Re: Steve Jobs Doesn't Want Shit In His App Store, And Neither Do I

#9

Post by rimantas »

z5h wrote: post #8

This guy uses jQuery on some of his sites. The language used in jQuery's selectors is a superset of CSS. That's right, it's not CSS. jQuery is translating/interpreting that new language for you. jQuery is more than just JavaScript it's an interpreter/compiler for a new language. (FYI, not allowed by Apple's rules). For some reason when this guy target multiple browsers using jQuery it's OK. But when other developers…

  jQuery is translating/interpreting that new language
  for you. jQuery is more than just JavaScript it's an
  interpreter/compiler for a new language.
What? Care to explain what does jQuer "compile" your "new language" to? The fact that jQuery uses CSS syntax to target DOM elements does not turn it into compiler. Or are you saying that it somehow runs the selector?
Post reply on HN