Live data from Hacker News

Wild flower blooms again after 30,000 years on ice (2012)

nature.com

1–10 of 60 posts

Re: Wild flower blooms again after 30,000 years on ice (2012)

#4

Somewhat misleading title, but a very interesting read nonetheless. "Welcome... To Neolithic Park!"

What's misleading about it? Did you read it as saying the flower bloomed naturally after thawing without human help?

The flower itself didn't so much bloom after being frozen, as cultivated tissue was worked in vitro to produce a viable flower. It's not exactly clickbait given the payoff, but it's still less than truthful IMO.

Re: Wild flower blooms again after 30,000 years on ice (2012)

#5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's misleading about it? Did you read it as saying the flower bloomed naturally after thawing without human help?

The flower itself didn't so much bloom after being frozen, as cultivated tissue was worked in vitro to produce a viable flower. It's not exactly clickbait given the payoff, but it's still less than truthful IMO.

I guess I automatically assumed it was a human-assisted process since the link was to nature.com, although in hindsight it would have been equally publishable, if not more so, if the flower bloomed on its own.

Re: Wild flower blooms again after 30,000 years on ice (2012)

#6

Somewhat misleading title, but a very interesting read nonetheless. "Welcome... To Neolithic Park!"

What's misleading about it? Did you read it as saying the flower bloomed naturally after thawing without human help?

Actually thats exactly what I thought it would be. Expected to see an area in the Tundra's with a wildflower bed.

Re: Wild flower blooms again after 30,000 years on ice (2012)

#10
post #9

When talking about megafauna resurrection, it is often said that it's not possible because DNA degrades too much after a few thousand years. Yet apparently the DNA of this plant was still viable. What am I missing?

Perhaps plant DNA is hardier against time, bacteria, freeze/thaw cycles, etc than animal DNA? I'm not a biologist, so I'd also love to know.
Post reply on HN