Live data from Hacker News

Thinking Machine 6: Play chess against a transparent intelligence

bewitched.com

1–10 of 24 posts

Re: Thinking Machine 6: Play chess against a transparent intelligence

#2
I love the idea. Not sure if it is the best visual. What does a strong line mean versus a thin line? Does it mean you are thinking real hard about that route? I know it would be much more effort but it would be interesting to read what it is thinking. Which piece is it trying to get in the short term. What is the long-term rational.

Re: Thinking Machine 6: Play chess against a transparent intelligence

#3
post #2

I love the idea. Not sure if it is the best visual. What does a strong line mean versus a thin line? Does it mean you are thinking real hard about that route? I know it would be much more effort but it would be interesting to read what it is thinking. Which piece is it trying to get in the short term. What is the long-term rational.

What bugs me the most is that it doesn't use anything even resembling standard iconography for the pieces.

Re: Thinking Machine 6: Play chess against a transparent intelligence

#4
post #2

I love the idea. Not sure if it is the best visual. What does a strong line mean versus a thin line? Does it mean you are thinking real hard about that route? I know it would be much more effort but it would be interesting to read what it is thinking. Which piece is it trying to get in the short term. What is the long-term rational.

[deleted]

Re: Thinking Machine 6: Play chess against a transparent intelligence

#5
post #3
post #2

I love the idea. Not sure if it is the best visual. What does a strong line mean versus a thin line? Does it mean you are thinking real hard about that route? I know it would be much more effort but it would be interesting to read what it is thinking. Which piece is it trying to get in the short term. What is the long-term rational.

What bugs me the most is that it doesn't use anything even resembling standard iconography for the pieces.

Yeah, I'm likely not going to be able to keep track of the pieces after a few moves.

Re: Thinking Machine 6: Play chess against a transparent intelligence

#6
Would be more interesting if it actually played chess. I mated it, it captured my queen with its king, I captured its king with a pawn, and then it declared a draw.

The end result: http://imgur.com/WoFSJcr

People should polish a little more before releasing these things. Who knows what the visualization means if the rules are this broken.

Re: Thinking Machine 6: Play chess against a transparent intelligence

#10

Would be more interesting if it actually played chess. I mated it, it captured my queen with its king, I captured its king with a pawn, and then it declared a draw. The end result: http://imgur.com/WoFSJcr People should polish a little more before releasing these things. Who knows what the visualization means if the rules are this broken.

That sounds a lot like playing any game with a young child. The difference is you can't correct a game-playing AI when it doesn't follow the rules.

So in a way it's a lot like playing a game with a young child after you've stopped caring about the rules.

Post reply on HN