Live data from Hacker News

Recognizing magic as a rare and valuable art form and national treasure

congress.gov

1–10 of 44 posts

Re: Recognizing magic as a rare and valuable art form and national treasure

#5
post #3

>Whereas magic enables people to experience the impossible Someone really didn't put much thought into this statement. And all the references to Project Magic does lead me to consider who put them up to proposing this

What's wrong with "experience the impossible"? Seems like a reasonable description of the situation to me, that's the whole point of magic.

Re: Recognizing magic as a rare and valuable art form and national treasure

#6
post #3

>Whereas magic enables people to experience the impossible Someone really didn't put much thought into this statement. And all the references to Project Magic does lead me to consider who put them up to proposing this

Marketing for the new, US-focused Harry Potter movie? :)

Re: Recognizing magic as a rare and valuable art form and national treasure

#7
post #3

>Whereas magic enables people to experience the impossible Someone really didn't put much thought into this statement. And all the references to Project Magic does lead me to consider who put them up to proposing this

What's wrong with "experience the impossible"? Seems like a reasonable description of the situation to me, that's the whole point of magic.

If magic existed it would, by definition, be neither impossible nor supernatural.

Re: Recognizing magic as a rare and valuable art form and national treasure

#9
The English language seems to be missing some word that other languages have.

In Dutch, "goochelen", performed by a "goochelaar" is doing tricks in a show, where you know it's all illusions but it's still very impressive. On the other hand, "toveren", done by a "tovenaar" would be doing something supernatural. Typically a "goochelaar" is somebody on a stage with a black top hat, while a "tovenaar" is more like an old man with a long white beard and a purple pointy hat in fiction.

In English, both seem to be called "magic". It's very confusing...

Post reply on HN