Live data from Hacker News

How one woman made a ‘tricorder’ that could change medicine [video]

bbc.com

1–10 of 19 posts

Re: How one woman made a ‘tricorder’ that could change medicine [video]

#2
TL;DR: The device in question, Gene Radar, is a "tricorder" only in the sense that it's a mobile health diagnostic tool, not in the Star Trek sense of a handheld external scanner that will will give you information about a person or object from a distance without direct physical contact. Based on the video in the article, it still requires a blood sample to be inserted for direct analysis. Really cool, but not quite a Star Trek tricorder just yet.

Re: How one woman made a ‘tricorder’ that could change medicine [video]

#4

TL;DR: The device in question, Gene Radar, is a "tricorder" only in the sense that it's a mobile health diagnostic tool, not in the Star Trek sense of a handheld external scanner that will will give you information about a person or object from a distance without direct physical contact. Based on the video in the article, it still requires a blood sample to be inserted for direct analysis. Really cool, but not quite…

I was curious about the list of conditions it can detect. I wonder how long it takes, how long between uses, what the maintenance is. When will I be able to walk into Walgreens and get my results?

"enables gold standard real-time diagnosis of any disease with a genetic fingerprint"

Re: How one woman made a ‘tricorder’ that could change medicine [video]

#5
I actually think that is massively cool. In particular for remote areas or for natural disaster response where local hospitals could be unsafe/unavailable.

I will say comparing it to a "tricorder" does the device a disservice. It isn't even trying to be one, it is trying to be something else entirely, and all it will get for being called that is criticism that it isn't tricorder-enough.

Re: How one woman made a ‘tricorder’ that could change medicine [video]

#9

TL;DR: The device in question, Gene Radar, is a "tricorder" only in the sense that it's a mobile health diagnostic tool, not in the Star Trek sense of a handheld external scanner that will will give you information about a person or object from a distance without direct physical contact. Based on the video in the article, it still requires a blood sample to be inserted for direct analysis. Really cool, but not quite…

Even with the blood sample "shortcoming", it will be huge if it keeps to its promise.

But I learned not to get excited by new medical inventions before a few years pass, before it's FDA approved, before there are enough studies that prove it really does what it says it does, etc.

Cool video. A woman writing some formulas, nano technology, DNA sequences, etc. All cool stuff.

Theranos also had some cool stuff to show but...

Re: How one woman made a ‘tricorder’ that could change medicine [video]

#10
post #9

TL;DR: The device in question, Gene Radar, is a "tricorder" only in the sense that it's a mobile health diagnostic tool, not in the Star Trek sense of a handheld external scanner that will will give you information about a person or object from a distance without direct physical contact. Based on the video in the article, it still requires a blood sample to be inserted for direct analysis. Really cool, but not quite…

Even with the blood sample "shortcoming", it will be huge if it keeps to its promise. But I learned not to get excited by new medical inventions before a few years pass, before it's FDA approved, before there are enough studies that prove it really does what it says it does, etc. Cool video. A woman writing some formulas, nano technology, DNA sequences, etc. All cool stuff. Theranos also had some cool stuff to show b…

I agree, it's super cheesy/cliche that she is writing formulas on windows and stuff, but it makes for nice TV.
Post reply on HN