Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Police in your country

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 23 posts

Ask HN: Police in your country

#1
I'm interested to know the general opinion of the Police force in various countries.

I am from the UK and more so than ever I feel suspicious/guilty when I see a police officer, as opposed to safe/protected.

Post your country and your opinion in the comments.

Re: Ask HN: Police in your country

#3
I'm from France (and white, sadly it matters) so I never encounter police once in my life (literally), and I'm actually "scared" of them, I don't trust them.

If a police officer stops me, I would actually be very defensive, a police officer or a gangster stop me I would have the same kind of state of mind, nothing good can come out of it, the best outcome is nothing happens.

I was also in Cameroon for a month (still white) and boy every time I saw the police I knew I would be arrested and asked for money. Being white I knew I would be arrested every time they saw me but make no mistake, they arrests and steal everyone including their fellow citizens. Good stuff.

Re: Ask HN: Police in your country

#6
Another data point from the UK:

I feel relaxed and safe when I encounter the police. Were I stopped an officer I would do my best to assist them, and to be courteous. I would be surprised if the courtesy were not returned. My interactions with the police have all been positive.

FWIW I'm white British and I live in a pretty 'typical' area, crime-wise. I accept there's a good chance I would feel differently were I a young black male living in London.

Re: Ask HN: Police in your country

#7
In Canada. Ethnic looking, but it doesn't matter. Feel a little lighter than the feeling of cops in London. They're there to help, but don't waste their time or distract them. I feel safe enough to call if I were in trouble or safe enough to go to a station for official business.

Reminds me of that old saw, Heaven is where: The French are the chefs The Italians are the lovers The British are the police The Germans are the mechanics And the Swiss make everything run on time.

Re: Ask HN: Police in your country

#8
American. I used to get really nervous around police (my dad doesn't trust them, and that rubbed off on me), and I still get nervous when I'm driving with a cop behind me.

I used to be scared of police, but as I got to know a few cops and ex-cops and as I researched more statistics about police in America, I've grown to sympathize with them.

I think my attitude towards them is most similar to my attitude towards my immediate superiors at work: they could make my life hell if they wanted to, but they're generally good people.

I worry about non-LEOs that carry guns. Cops don't worry or bother me anymore. They're unpopular right now (thank you, sensationalist media), but they're generally doing a good job. I feel safe.

Re: Ask HN: Police in your country

#9
I'm a white male from Texas, which probably weighs into my experiences a great deal. It mostly feels like police officers want to be your friend and end the encounter with you as soon a possible unless you've done something wrong (like speeding or other small offenses) in which case they seem to act more like an angry and bothered parent. Overall it seems like they don't want to have to deal with people unless they feel like they have to.

Re: Ask HN: Police in your country

#10
Hi, interesting post.

First I wanted to say USA may be different from others in the fact that silence can't be hold against you. If police detain you, the advice I hear from lawyers is to zip it. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZGgKLgVNfAo is a great presentation featuring a former detective and a defense attorney)

In other countries, like UK - not giving an alibi in situ can be used against you.

In USA - I trust the integrity of the legal system, but the police are trained to use deception - ranging from gigantic pretexts, like posing as your telephone repair man, to simple bluffs and lies. (Funny spoof: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DfF8OSlGhKk)

This creates a chilling effect of distrust which discourages informants. No one worth his salt can take a cop at his or her word. And I think the cumulative result that has on communities is drowned in relation to what we see with cop violence in the public eye.

Not having a line between community and police means cases can go unsolved and serious crime can go unpunished.

Post reply on HN